TOPIC:

Clear-View wrote:

BC wrote: How do you know that? Do you have info on what they were paid? Collectively they would have accounted for a big chunk of the salary cap given they were all in the best 22 at the club.

It’s not hard to work out when you look at the facts,

Baker hadn’t played a senior game prior to 2017
Ryan got to Subi 2016 played reserves and league
Hancock played 1 game in 2016 after coming from EF in 2015
Adamson was playing reserves at EP in 2015 & 2016
Jackson played reserves in 2014 2015 & 2017

These guys would have been in the lower paid bracket on the list. Twomey would have been on reasonable coin.

So bottom line from what you’ve thrown up given all those players would have been replaced with paid players is Twomey for Clarke. FMD Clarke was on more than the entire player cap the year before. Blind Freddy can see the numbers don’t add up.

What’s needed is more stringent policing of the total player payment cap.

You asked who we lost at the end of 2017 to accommodate Zac Clarke in 2018 so I told you. In 2017 Twomey played 23 games, Hancock 19, Adamson 20, Jackson 18, Baker 13 and Ryan 23. All played in the GF that year so reckon that's a pretty big turnover of quality players and would account for a reasonable piece of the salary cap given ressies don't get paid.

Perhaps open both your eyes rather than the one Subi eye. I didn’t ask who you lost I asked who were the top end players in your salary cap that left at the end of 2017.

The players you named other than perhaps Twomey would have been mainly bottom end players in your 2017 payments given the facts provided from previous seasons. They played well in 2017 and were in the GF but this would have had virtually no impact on your payments as they are basically set prior to the season beginning.

When you factor in they were all replaced (I can’t be bothered listing your 2018 recruits other than Clarke) and weren’t costing you much to begin with blind Freddy can see that the numbers don’t add up.

So you're saying that if 6 of your best 22 left your club at the end of 2017 it wouldn't impact on the salary cap in 2018?....oh that's right...WCE paid the salaries of your players so you didn't have one..no wonder you're struggling to understand the concept.

Oh dear the toys have been thrown out of the cot. Comprehension not your strong suit?

I think everyone needs to have a bex and a lie down to be honest.

mikeh wrote: I think everyone needs to have a bex and a lie down to be honest.

especially the Train driver and his conductor Mikeh....kinda going round and round this.....

Clear-View wrote: Oh dear the toys have been thrown out of the cot. Comprehension not your strong suit?

You're happy to make certain insinuations against my club but don't like it when it comes back at you...go figure.