TOPIC:

Dirty Weekender wrote: BH, just out of sick interest, in a hypothethical world, if you had to choose between Simon Beasley or Brent Hutton in their prime as your full forward who would you go for???

Loved both of them DW hence the name but I would probably have to choose Simon 'Pieman' Beasley for the FF spot as he not only won the Naylor Medal but also the Coleman Medal as well ..with Brent 'Hunky' Hutton in the forward pocket ..and I might also slot Garry 'Sidey' Sidebottom in at CHF mate!!

Beasley Hutton wrote:

Dirty Weekender wrote: BH, just out of sick interest, in a hypothethical world, if you had to choose between Simon Beasley or Brent Hutton in their prime as your full forward who would you go for???

Loved both of them DW hence the name but I would probably have to choose Simon 'Pieman' Beasley for the FF spot as he not only won the Naylor Medal but also the Coleman Medal as well ..with Brent 'Hunky' Hutton in the forward pocket ..and I might also slot Garry 'Sidey' Sidebottom in at CHF mate!!

Hunky for me but purely based on entertainment value. Never will forget the way he launched at the ball on the lead. Like a cross between Dunstall & Capper, a rare breed! Excuse my ignorance but why did they call Beasley the Pieman?

Still have Tony Notte that can ruck and why not bring Blight in for a jump or 2. He has a huge leap on him and after all he got drafted to Collingwood for his midfield work in colts.

Dirty Weekender wrote:

Beasley Hutton wrote:

Dirty Weekender wrote: BH, just out of sick interest, in a hypothethical world, if you had to choose between Simon Beasley or Brent Hutton in their prime as your full forward who would you go for???

Loved both of them DW hence the name but I would probably have to choose Simon 'Pieman' Beasley for the FF spot as he not only won the Naylor Medal but also the Coleman Medal as well ..with Brent 'Hunky' Hutton in the forward pocket ..and I might also slot Garry 'Sidey' Sidebottom in at CHF mate!!

Hunky for me but purely based on entertainment value. Never will forget the way he launched at the ball on the lead. Like a cross between Dunstall & Capper, a rare breed! Excuse my ignorance but why did they call Beasley the Pieman?

Rhymes with Simon DW ..Hutton was won of the best aerialists I have seen in my time and his 84 Naylor Medal winning season was a ripper including 5 snags in the GF!

Kingstone wrote: Still have Tony Notte that can ruck and why not bring Blight in for a jump or 2. He has a huge leap on him and after all he got drafted to Collingwood for his midfield work in colts.

Blight & Rogers have to come in to the side for mine this week.

Hutton for me ... loved him as a kid growing up on the hill

I think it is obvious who the floggers are here. Have a good look at yourselves.

Wes is yet another casualty to the Harding/Smart murder of the playing group. Wes going should be the last straw. The board must act now and rid the club of the cancer that is Harding/Smart.

Percy is no longer at the club thanks to the above gentleman too.

Pull your heads in before you abuse a player who has given his all and more for the club. I have known Lobb for years too but Lammie should have been in as a second ruckman at least. He is the fittest player on the list.

Shame on Harding once again. The player list hardly resembles anything from swans zone. He has brought in all outsiders from other WAFL clubs. The colts are a shambles with kids also walking out left right at centre. The colts coach wants out. The reserves coach has caught the disease of the league coach, telling players what they want to hear and acting otherwise.

MacAttack wrote: I think it is obvious who the floggers are here. Have a good look at yourselves.

Wes is yet another casualty to the Harding/Smart murder of the playing group. Wes going should be the last straw. The board must act now and rid the club of the cancer that is Harding/Smart.

Percy is no longer at the club thanks to the above gentleman too.

Pull your heads in before you abuse a player who has given his all and more for the club. I have known Lobb for years too but Lammie should have been in as a second ruckman at least. He is the fittest player on the list.

Shame on Harding once again. The player list hardly resembles anything from swans zone. He has brought in all outsiders from other WAFL clubs. The colts are a shambles with kids also walking out left right at centre. The colts coach wants out. The reserves coach has caught the disease of the league coach, telling players what they want to hear and acting otherwise.

MacAttack a couple of things. Percy was at Basso last Saturday. How would you rate Lobb's performances during Lammie's absence? Given that Harding supported and selected Lammie over Spandermann a couple of years ago; you can hardly suggest that Lammie has not been treated reasonably and fairly by Harding. Further, given that Lammie had missed some training would it not have been reasonable for him to play a game in the ressies?

On what basis do you say that the colts' coach wants to leave? Given that we are giving colts' players the opportunity to play ressies with the view of breaking into the league team next year; how does that lead to an exodus of colts' players?

Lammie is on another planet if he thinks he doesnt have to come back through the reserves after having a leg injury..

Bloody disapointing if this is the case!! I thought Wes had a stress fracture or something?? Missed three or four weeks and young Lobb has done really well in his absense although struggled a little last week. If he has left because he was to play reserves last week coming back after three or four weeks off then that is pretty ordinary. I would have thought your leading ruckman would be helping Lobb get better and being a strong role model not be threatened by him.
Gee don't know what to think......................