TOPIC:

swan42 wrote:

chaddy22 wrote:

BC wrote: last time i looked subi had to adhere to the same points cap as every other non-aligned team so can't for the life of me see how we're limiting opportunities for young blokes coming through like WART and FART and the other 6 teams aren't.

It has nothing to do with points but opportunity.Just as there is limited opportunities fo local players at aligned clubs you can make the same point for g7 clubs.At least 10 of last week's subi side came from outside their zone.I have had enough of this myth that because you are at a aligned club you arelimiting opportunities.Go thru g7 lists and you will find nearly all clubs habve a high proportion of recruits in the league side restricting a pathway for local juniors.thus endeth the lesson

C22 perhaps you can start with Swans.

Let me help you C22. From our game against West Perth on Monday and BH feel free to add any names I have forgotten:

1. Joshua Kirkup (High Wycombe 11th league game on Monday)
12. Rudy Riddoch (BASSENDEAN 10th game)
13. Jacob Coniglio (La Salle 3rd game)
14. Jake Nuich (Swan Athletic 5th game)
34. Sean Fletcher (Midvale DEBUT)
36. Jason Daniels (Bassendean 6th game)
47. Warwick Wilson (Clontarf/SDFC Colts 2014 3rd game)

More experienced local players from Monday's game included:

2. Jarrad Blight (Midvale)
6. Kirk Ugle (Carey Park)
7. Adam Faulkner (La Salle)
11. Tallan Ames (Trinity)
24. Justin Simpson (Forrestfield)
25. Alex Howard (Swan View)
28. Tony Notte ((Upper Swan)
29. Nathan Broad (Upper Swan)

Compare your list with our opponents this week 42 & their list of home grown talent vs C (hopefully I have enough room on the page to list them all).

Josh Mathers (Warnbro)

Beasley Hutton wrote: Compare your list with our opponents this week 42 & their list of home grown talent vs C (hopefully I have enough room on the page to list them all).

Josh Mathers (Warnbro)

Feel free to append to my list other locally produced Swans players who have played league this year.

We had 15 locals play yesterday.

Next.

swan42 wrote:

swan42 wrote:

chaddy22 wrote:

BC wrote: last time i looked subi had to adhere to the same points cap as every other non-aligned team so can't for the life of me see how we're limiting opportunities for young blokes coming through like WART and FART and the other 6 teams aren't.

It has nothing to do with points but opportunity.Just as there is limited opportunities fo local players at aligned clubs you can make the same point for g7 clubs.At least 10 of last week's subi side came from outside their zone.I have had enough of this myth that because you are at a aligned club you arelimiting opportunities.Go thru g7 lists and you will find nearly all clubs habve a high proportion of recruits in the league side restricting a pathway for local juniors.thus endeth the lesson

C22 perhaps you can start with Swans.

Let me help you C22. From our game against West Perth on Monday and BH feel free to add any names I have forgotten:

1. Joshua Kirkup (High Wycombe 11th league game on Monday)
12. Rudy Riddoch (BASSENDEAN 10th game)
13. Jacob Coniglio (La Salle 3rd game)
14. Jake Nuich (Swan Athletic 5th game)
34. Sean Fletcher (Midvale DEBUT)
36. Jason Daniels (Bassendean 6th game)
47. Warwick Wilson (Clontarf/SDFC Colts 2014 3rd game)

More experienced local players from Monday's game included:

2. Jarrad Blight (Midvale)
6. Kirk Ugle (Carey Park)
7. Adam Faulkner (La Salle)
11. Tallan Ames (Trinity)
24. Justin Simpson (Forrestfield)
25. Alex Howard (Swan View)
28. Tony Notte ((Upper Swan)
29. Nathan Broad (Upper Swan)

I think i have solved the reason west perth beat you.Maybe if you had less former perth footballers playing for you it may have been a different result.

chaddy22 wrote:

swan42 wrote:

swan42 wrote:

chaddy22 wrote:

BC wrote: last time i looked subi had to adhere to the same points cap as every other non-aligned team so can't for the life of me see how we're limiting opportunities for young blokes coming through like WART and FART and the other 6 teams aren't.

It has nothing to do with points but opportunity.Just as there is limited opportunities fo local players at aligned clubs you can make the same point for g7 clubs.At least 10 of last week's subi side came from outside their zone.I have had enough of this myth that because you are at a aligned club you arelimiting opportunities.Go thru g7 lists and you will find nearly all clubs habve a high proportion of recruits in the league side restricting a pathway for local juniors.thus endeth the lesson

C22 perhaps you can start with Swans.

Let me help you C22. From our game against West Perth on Monday and BH feel free to add any names I have forgotten:

1. Joshua Kirkup (High Wycombe 11th league game on Monday)
12. Rudy Riddoch (BASSENDEAN 10th game)
13. Jacob Coniglio (La Salle 3rd game)
14. Jake Nuich (Swan Athletic 5th game)
34. Sean Fletcher (Midvale DEBUT)
36. Jason Daniels (Bassendean 6th game)
47. Warwick Wilson (Clontarf/SDFC Colts 2014 3rd game)

More experienced local players from Monday's game included:

2. Jarrad Blight (Midvale)
6. Kirk Ugle (Carey Park)
7. Adam Faulkner (La Salle)
11. Tallan Ames (Trinity)
24. Justin Simpson (Forrestfield)
25. Alex Howard (Swan View)
28. Tony Notte ((Upper Swan)
29. Nathan Broad (Upper Swan)

I think i have solved the reason west perth beat you.Maybe if you had less former perth footballers playing for you it may have been a different result.

Chaddy not your normal style to make silly comments like the above. Hopefully tongue in cheek or has someone hit a raw nerve?

mikeh wrote:

chaddy22 wrote:

swan42 wrote:

swan42 wrote:

chaddy22 wrote:

BC wrote: last time i looked subi had to adhere to the same points cap as every other non-aligned team so can't for the life of me see how we're limiting opportunities for young blokes coming through like WART and FART and the other 6 teams aren't.

It has nothing to do with points but opportunity.Just as there is limited opportunities fo local players at aligned clubs you can make the same point for g7 clubs.At least 10 of last week's subi side came from outside their zone.I have had enough of this myth that because you are at a aligned club you arelimiting opportunities.Go thru g7 lists and you will find nearly all clubs habve a high proportion of recruits in the league side restricting a pathway for local juniors.thus endeth the lesson

C22 perhaps you can start with Swans.

Let me help you C22. From our game against West Perth on Monday and BH feel free to add any names I have forgotten:

1. Joshua Kirkup (High Wycombe 11th league game on Monday)
12. Rudy Riddoch (BASSENDEAN 10th game)
13. Jacob Coniglio (La Salle 3rd game)
14. Jake Nuich (Swan Athletic 5th game)
34. Sean Fletcher (Midvale DEBUT)
36. Jason Daniels (Bassendean 6th game)
47. Warwick Wilson (Clontarf/SDFC Colts 2014 3rd game)

More experienced local players from Monday's game included:

2. Jarrad Blight (Midvale)
6. Kirk Ugle (Carey Park)
7. Adam Faulkner (La Salle)
11. Tallan Ames (Trinity)
24. Justin Simpson (Forrestfield)
25. Alex Howard (Swan View)
28. Tony Notte ((Upper Swan)
29. Nathan Broad (Upper Swan)

I think i have solved the reason west perth beat you.Maybe if you had less former perth footballers playing for you it may have been a different result.

Chaddy not your normal style to make silly comments like the above. Hopefully tongue in cheek or has someone hit a raw nerve?

Mikeh I can understand why C22 would be bitter and twisted and jealous of Swans; we still have a club to support. What has C22 got to support? A shell of a club where the league team is East Perth in name only.