TOPIC:

Really tricky as Swans+ Perth can't pick Alex Rance + Buddy Franklin or Stephan Coniglio.Before there Stella AFL careers when they where rookies at there Wafl clubs.
Swans
1.Andrew Krakourer
2.Shane Beros
3.Lewis Jetta
4.Tony Notte
5.Tommy Roach
Apologies to the other 20 contenders.Or another 5 different players.
1.Ryan Davis
2.Tallam Aimes
3.Corey Gault
4.Matt Riggio
5.Tim Geappon

Also hard to leave out Rix and Webb

Yes...I thought about making it top 10 or even 20 but by reducing the number to 5 it does make people think about it a bit more. When everyone has had a chance to contribute, I'll tally up each club and list the top 5 by consensus.

BC wrote: Yes...I thought about making it top 10 or even 20 but by reducing the number to 5 it does make people think about it a bit more. When everyone has had a chance to contribute, I'll tally up each club and list the top 5 by consensus.

Ok then hard to argue with your list BC, remembering Parker also did a lot of ruck work giving away a lot of size, so just in ahead of Dela

BC wrote:

Mr AFL wrote: So this is purely 2010-2019?

Yes...sorry...this century so from 2000 onwards.

Okay. Well if we were to go purely on best players coming from Perth then Buddy Franklin but he only played one league game for Perth so didn't really have any impact for us.

I'll go top 5 players for Perth from 2000.

1. Ross Young
2. Troy Cook
3. Dene White
4. Aidan Tropiano
5. Michael Sinclair

There's certainly some quality there Mr AFL...I'm surprised no Clint Jones but I guess you can't put everyone in.

bc -- that is why you were right to keep it at five: people have to make some genuine decisions in their selections. I picked Dellhunty, because, in the gfs against peel we would have been nowhere without him. The first Peel side was one of the best sides of seen in the WAFL since 1987. Me thinks that a couple of early CL sides would have beaten them.

Certainly no argument from me in putting Delahunty in your top 5 AR. He is as we know a very, very good player. I guess I went for Aiden Parker due to his longevity and sustained excellence on the footy field. I have no doubt Dela will be in the conversation when he finishes as I think he's still got a good year or two in him to achieve even more. He's right up there even now on being the best interstate recruit we've had this century.

BC wrote: There's certainly some quality there Mr AFL...I'm surprised no Clint Jones but I guess you can't put everyone in.

I can't believe I missed him. Completely bloody forgot about Jones. Don't know how but I just did. Okay revised top 5 would see Sinclair missing out and Jones in at 3 with White coming in at 4 and Tropiano at 5.

1. Coniglio
2. Nic Nat
3. Walters
4. Krakouer
5. Rance

WAFL players
1. Notte
2. Ames
3. Riggio
4. Geappen
5. Josh Roberts