TOPIC:

Yes I believe the Mosman Park umpire's a complete cowboy and his choices and decisions whilst adjudicating the game are somewhat questionable but I strongly do believe all of you need to get the fuck over it. Whinging and ranting that kicks aren't going your way is a part of the game but you don't need to take that shit off the field. Accept that the game is sometimes out of your hands and umpire's get it wrong.
I wanted to king hit the umpire in the first half when we played them on their home turf because even the little things he said like niggling against your opponent when you're just retaliating and he pulls you up when they are giving it back to you the same if not more and the complete disregard for high swinging elbows and off the ball contact being overlooked.

With all that being said I think it is also blame on the other clubs umpire for not overruling the completely obscure or blatantly incorrect decisions. Not much more to say just leave the umpire's alone and let them work it out and do their job.

Block Yole.....I think that rather than telling people to get the fuck over it I think the real questions need to be asked of the Mosman Park football club being:

1) Are they happy with their umpire and the standard he sets
2) Are they confident he is following the rules properly and calling the game fairly
3) How will they go in finals if they don't have this umpire and
4) if they answer no to any of those questions above what are they going to do about it.

I understand everyone's frustrations, clearly the people running Mosman park football club don't have a different take on things if they are happy and every opponent they play against complains about the same issues.

So I don't think its right to say get the fuck over it......I think you should have said something like Mosman Park, how can you be satisfied with this crap being thrown at your club and what are you going to do about it. Right now you seem to be the laughing stock of your grade............

Has anyone tried to get in contact with MPFC?
Maybe someone should get in touch with the MPFC heirachy (in writing) and see what their response is. If the response isnt up to scratch then forward it onto the league admin and see if they can view one of these games and maybe action will take place.

Hooray

The last 2 weeks a panel umpire has been appointed to mossy parks league game
And what happens they lost those 2 games

Just shows you get nowhere with such a pathetic cheating umpire that they have

Congratulation mosman park.

A job well done to all the teams that pay the waafl to appoint this action within there games
It's a shame that the clubs need to dig extra into there pockets for a fair game .

Arnt you the person bagging out his own football club on another post?

footylad25 wrote: Arnt you the person bagging out his own football club on another post?

You from Mossy i take it...

Can someone tell me why this ump got the boot from Mossie park...Im pretty sure we had him this weekend...what a friggin joke he is.if its him,he should never umpire another game of footy again.
I just need details of his constant stuff ups.......no need to post on here .please PM me.
Blokes like him stuff our great game

How do we all feel about having WAAFL panel appointed umpires for the rest of the season? Should be interesting in all grades below C1 on how they handle some decent umpiring who can also run out a game!!

Club umpires appointed by league doesn't make them panel umpires. Lower grades will get some of these. League games won't but some lower reserves and D, E grades will.

Hopefully we get some decent ones though.

Viper wrote: Club umpires appointed by league doesn't make them panel umpires. Lower grades will get some of these. League games won't but some lower reserves and D, E grades will.

Hopefully we get some decent ones though.

As A grade is still playing round 18 this week the league use a handful of carefully selected club umpires (IE decent ones) in the lower grades and reserve games for the first two weeks of the finals. The majority of league games will have panel umpires