TOPIC:

Freezin wrote: But did it work in 2016 mate?....Wiley was 5/2 by midseason mate....then guess what?....EF won 4 games for the rest of the season.....then 3 in 2017 and 2 in 2018....of course Billy gets a free swing....he has had only 1 season....come and find me after season 3 mate to ask my opinion of Billy at EF....be happy to give a fair comparison then....but kind a think you have already got your mind made up about Billy after 1 season....strange how Earl keeps getting a free swing after 7 though....

Perhaps you are tired after a long day. You are up very late tonight. You got to be up early tomorrow to get the low down on the big arbitration.

Facts please Joker. Duke has had only 5 seasons and wont get a 7th. Gary Moss will be the coach in 2021.

stt I think all good coaches divide opinion

armstrong
todd
brown and so on

what has Bill got? As many flags as Brown?

Show me a good coach doing well and having success with an average list.

Ken Armstrong, dd, your own -- comparred to the teams he beat
Bill won his against better teams
John Dimmer
Brad Smith

ArkRoyal wrote: stt I think all good coaches divide opinion

armstrong
todd
brown and so on

what has Bill got? As many flags as Brown?

Brown- 2 (1972, 1980)
Bill- 1 (2013)

Bh -- thanks for that correction mate

I would have dimmer and Dawson as the best two coaches since 1987

Neesham
Schofield
German

all had pretty good sides, me thinks

it is amazing to me that dimmer has never coached Subiaco

Of course it's the list, not the coach. Look at Pagan and Malthouse at Carlton, German at Peel, Watters at St Kilda, etc. Everyone knows that if Subi and Swans swapped coaches last year, they would have finished in the exact same position.

only in part though ted: perth would not have won in 1976 without Armstrong
ken smith had the same list in 1981 at eF and did naff all

Back to topic of this thread.... Intra Club match 5 March and another on on 13th March. 21st March there is a Pre Season match v the Cheats of the last 10 years at Leederville Reserves at 130 and League at 4pm.

smokey wrote:

Freezin wrote: But did it work in 2016 mate?....Wiley was 5/2 by midseason mate....then guess what?....EF won 4 games for the rest of the season.....then 3 in 2017 and 2 in 2018....of course Billy gets a free swing....he has had only 1 season....come and find me after season 3 mate to ask my opinion of Billy at EF....be happy to give a fair comparison then....but kind a think you have already got your mind made up about Billy after 1 season....strange how Earl keeps getting a free swing after 7 though....

Perhaps you are tired after a long day. You are up very late tonight. You got to be up early tomorrow to get the low down on the big arbitration.

Facts please Joker. Duke has had only 5 seasons and wont get a 7th. Gary Moss will be the coach in 2021.

True Smokester....apologies for that ...5 free swings it is then mate ...four more than Billy......as for being up late mate....actually been in Perth for the past week mate LOL...but thanks for the concern.....fly out from terminal one tomorrow at 0700 if you want to give me a proper send off....