TOPIC:

swan42 wrote: No sacko - everyone knows that not every breach of the rules is penalised. How many times in a game is a player penalised for running too far and how many times in a game is a player not penalised when patently they have run too far. You cannot grab a player without the ball and how many throws are not penalised?

Also for 30pyd does an umpire yell play on every time a player kicks the ball after a free kick or a mark?

So how do you propose to fix this problem of incompetent umpires who do not know the rules? According to you and your mates every umpire today in every comp do not have a clue. What's your solution because if you ask me unless your willing to have a crack yourself or at least get a copy of the 2013 law book and not 1 that's five years old and actually read you've got nothing left

one thing is for sure, Perth supporters wont be on here complaining about the umpires this year after a loss after their posts this week

MarkOlsen wrote: one thing is for sure, Perth supporters wont be on here complaining about the umpires this year after a loss after their posts this week

Have you got anything else to contribute? That's been your line all week. Oh I forgot... The umps cost you every game you've ever lost right?

Now that I've seen the video on FB, it's obvious that is was a 50 metre penalty.

The Swans trainer threw the ball hard into the ground - seemingly in disgust. No attempt was made to give the ball back to the Perth player correctly.

<iframe src="www.facebook.com/video/embed?video_id=10151638718290774" width="568" height="320" frameborder="0">

dont worry Sacko, i'll be keeping a close eye on the Perth posts between now and the end of the year..

especially yours

reckon it will be very peaceful now in the pig pen that you blokes all agree that as long as the umps are technically right then that is all that matters

MarkOlsen wrote: dont worry Sacko, i'll be keeping a close eye on the Perth posts between now and the end of the year..

especially yours

reckon it will be very peaceful now in the pig pen that you blokes all agree that as long as the umps are technically right then that is all that matters

I know you'll be looking. You've been stalking blokes since the early FG days. It's a bit creepy

MarkOlsen wrote: one thing is for sure, Perth supporters wont be on here complaining about the umpires this year after a loss after their posts this week

Why because its been pointed out to you that the rule was broken and free paid accordinly???
It wasnt technically there it was plain and simple there!
Even a few neutral supporters have come on here and said "it was there"!!

Probably time to let this one go now guys and move on. Its been done to death on both this and the previously deleted post.

Sacko wrote:

MarkOlsen wrote: dont worry Sacko, i'll be keeping a close eye on the Perth posts between now and the end of the year..

especially yours

reckon it will be very peaceful now in the pig pen that you blokes all agree that as long as the umps are technically right then that is all that matters

I know you'll be looking. You've been stalking blokes since the early FG days. It's a bit creepy

hahahahahahahahah spot on brother.

Thanks La Hinch.

The video quite clearly shows the action taken by the official.

The first time I had seen it clearly.

Correct decision made, I agree with Mikeh time to move on.