TOPIC:

I dont think Butler is a passenger, when he plays he is consitent, beats his opponent more times than he gets beaten. Agree on Smith, he should go. McGinnity I like, hard at it and should be our best small defender, if he gets put in that position. Agree on Kerr and Embley.

Hutchings is not a uncontested ball winner? He is an in and under player. You always need outside mids, and if we have Priddis and Scott Selwood in the middle, their is really no need for another in and under mid.

Darling could definately be turned into a great midfielder, but I prefer his presence up forward, would be too hard to replace him up their, his tackling and pressure is second to none!!

You're right about Hutchings, he just couldn't buy a vowel the other night. Dalziell had more of it.
Wellingham, Priddis and Selwood were probably our best against the Cats.
No mention of Darling and Kennedy plus forwards alike, ball rarely went down there.
Shuey's first game back... glad he didn't pull a hammy.

Sorry Soprano, but McGinnity is rubbish. He has average disposal and I just dont think he is in WCE best 22. Just because he is hard at it, I dont think it warrants him getting a game.

Definately Wellingham, Priddis and Selwood were our best. Darling and Kennedy were quiet, but expected given the amount of ball that came down there. M.Brown, McKenzie and Glass were also not to fault. But god we miss Waters and Hurn down their.

I agree he does have average disposal (but so does E.McKenzie), but I think that he would be in our best 22 if he was played as a small defender (as I said before). But he is not being played as that. He should be taking A.Smith's opponents and he will be a lot better. Would be playing the same position as J.Brennan and I reckon McGinnity would be more valuable. McGinnity playing in the mids or fwd line, definately not in our best 22.

shwaborn wrote: Obviously WCE are not a wet weather footy team, not much chance of gaining more experience there.
If it was dry scores would have been different.
Stand out for me was the big difference in work rate, the Cats creamed it.
Ken Judge has been saying for a while now he believes the way the AFL is going is taller mids, or bigger bodies. The likes of Gaff, Dalziell, Hutchings, Cripps are generally uncontested ball winners. Too many of them. Maybe throw Darling in the middle and bring in Dick into the forward line to see the measure.

Cats win by 90+ points

Rumour has it, Woosha just quit.

Where'd ya hear that?

heard on am radio.
Maybe that's why Paul Roos said something has come up that he needs to think about..
Wishful thinking

Adam Simpson it is.
I am happy enough. I do prefer to think that the Hawks game plan is a little more desirable than the Dockers.
I would've been supportive either but the more I read about Simpson the more I'm happy.

shwaborn wrote: Adam Simpson it is.
I am happy enough. I do prefer to think that the Hawks game plan is a little more desirable than the Dockers.
I would've been supportive either but the more I read about Simpson the more I'm happy.

I agree,i think they needed someone from outside the club and whilst i feel for Sumich and Burns thats the nature of the business and by the sounds of it Simpsion interviewed very well,good luck to him.



ADAM SIMPSON
Born: February 16, 1976

PLAYING
Club: North Melbourne
Drafted: No.14 in 1993 national draft from Eltham/Northern U18
Career span: 1995-2009
Games: 306 (equal third highest in North Melbourne’s history behind Brent Harvey 362 and Glenn Archer 311 and equal with Wayne Schimmelbusch)
Honours: premiership sides 1996 and ’99; best and fairest 2002 (four other top-three placings); All-Australian 2002; club captain 2004-08

COACHING
Hawthorn assistant coach 2010-13

Read more: www.heraldsun.com.au/other-sports/west-c...-as-new-senior-coach