TOPIC:

mikeh wrote: If you get a chance have a read of a post on the Amateur board which has been initiated by a first timer and is titled "Revamped league" Since the news came out that the Amateur competition is going to be renamed the Perth Football league I have been wondering if this would also have implications for the WAFL long term. The post describes a potential model in quite a lot of detail and I would suggest people might like to read this and add their views.

I mean this in the kindest possible way, I didn't respond to the original post u refer to in the ammo section.

But seriously, the post is the most ill informed post that has been made by someone who has no understanding of both the wafl or ammo comps. - I actually thought it was swan42 who posted it. Basic fantasy.

However, wouldn't want to quash a new idea but without a basic understanding of the comps the post is irrelevant.

mikeh wrote:

Bazza wrote: Well looks like we might have got our answer today which club will face merger.

Might not be that simple Bazza. WAFC don't want to lose their presence in the North corridor so who would West Perth merge with?

Where did i say anyone or thing would be moving from the north, someone could be moving up there with them.

Unholytugboat wrote:

mikeh wrote: If you get a chance have a read of a post on the Amateur board which has been initiated by a first timer and is titled "Revamped league" Since the news came out that the Amateur competition is going to be renamed the Perth Football league I have been wondering if this would also have implications for the WAFL long term. The post describes a potential model in quite a lot of detail and I would suggest people might like to read this and add their views.

I mean this in the kindest possible way, I didn't respond to the original post u refer to in the ammo section.

But seriously, the post is the most ill informed post that has been made by someone who has no understanding of both the wafl or ammo comps. - I actually thought it was swan42 who posted it. Basic fantasy.

However, wouldn't want to quash a new idea but without a basic understanding of the comps the post is irrelevant.

mikeh are you as insulted as I am?

Unholytugboat wrote:

mikeh wrote: If you get a chance have a read of a post on the Amateur board which has been initiated by a first timer and is titled "Revamped league" Since the news came out that the Amateur competition is going to be renamed the Perth Football league I have been wondering if this would also have implications for the WAFL long term. The post describes a potential model in quite a lot of detail and I would suggest people might like to read this and add their views.

I mean this in the kindest possible way, I didn't respond to the original post u refer to in the ammo section.

But seriously, the post is the most ill informed post that has been made by someone who has no understanding of both the wafl or ammo comps. - I actually thought it was swan42 who posted it. Basic fantasy.

However, wouldn't want to quash a new idea but without a basic understanding of the comps the post is irrelevant.

I agree UHT that it is an ill informed post which lacks understanding, made by a first time poster for who knows what purpose.

Must admit that the post caught my eye because for a first time post, it was detailed and almost appeared to be from someone in the system with a specific agenda (I remember my first post on Footygoss a few years back went along the lines of "Hi I'm a Swans supporter, nice to meet you all")
I will put my hand up and say that I don't know enough about amateur footy to be able to give an informed opinion on the proposal and wanted to hear from others who did know more. It appears from what people have said so far that the proposal is not realistic..

It didn't make a lot of sense at all

Bazza wrote: It didn't make a lot of sense at all

No it didn't, my view is that it was probably Shorten's idea.