TOPIC:

As I said before don't feed the troll and he may go away.

Freezin wrote: 42....that's your opinion I'm using sarcasm....in reality I am merely stating a fact that a true test of ones overall ability is what opposition fans think of that player.....bias and subjectiveness clouds one opinion.....I think Simpson is a fantastic player for you boys.....is it a travesty he is not playing state footy......mmmmm no not really, it would of been though if the likes of Kenny, Dougie and Rosco weren't picked to represent WA during their hey day tho......ditto for Narkle, Baker et al

but no biggie mate.....you are a SD fan just merely supporting one of your own players.....a player you would watch more closely come match day than an opposing fan would do.....simply because they are watching their own players just as close.....it's ok to wear glasses mate....no matter how rose tinted or black/white they maybe.....just don't get all the subjective bias you guys come out with.......

as for attending the state game.....now Simmo and ROB aren't playing not much point really is there mate?....just won't be the same sadly....

Oh well my opinion is Stephen Dodd is a spud and from memory wasn't too flash last time he represented WA, gets towelled up most times he plays against SD too, probably why Gavin Brown (EF Backs coach) went white in the face when I informed him Swooper Geappen had decided to play on this year ..but just my opinion of course!!

Swandog wrote:

Freezin wrote: 42....that's your opinion I'm using sarcasm....in reality I am merely stating a fact that a true test of ones overall ability is what opposition fans think of that player.....bias and subjectiveness clouds one opinion.....I think Simpson is a fantastic player for you boys.....is it a travesty he is not playing state footy......mmmmm no not really, it would of been though if the likes of Kenny, Dougie and Rosco weren't picked to represent WA during their hey day tho......ditto for Narkle, Baker et al

but no biggie mate.....you are a SD fan just merely supporting one of your own players.....a player you would watch more closely come match day than an opposing fan would do.....simply because they are watching their own players just as close.....it's ok to wear glasses mate....no matter how rose tinted or black/white they maybe.....just don't get all the subjective bias you guys come out with.......

as for attending the state game.....now Simmo and ROB aren't playing not much point really is there mate?....just won't be the same sadly....

Oh well my opinion is Stephen Dodd is a spud and from memory wasn't too flash last time he represented WA, gets towelled up most times he plays against SD too, probably why Gavin Brown (EF Backs coach) went white in the face when I informed him Swooper Geappen had decided to play on this year ..but just my opinion of course!!

He wasnt the only EF bloke to go all white in the face over Swooper kicking on this year mate ..apparently ol frosty over in Enzed went as white as a ghost!!

Beasley Hutton wrote:

Swandog wrote:

Freezin wrote: 42....that's your opinion I'm using sarcasm....in reality I am merely stating a fact that a true test of ones overall ability is what opposition fans think of that player.....bias and subjectiveness clouds one opinion.....I think Simpson is a fantastic player for you boys.....is it a travesty he is not playing state footy......mmmmm no not really, it would of been though if the likes of Kenny, Dougie and Rosco weren't picked to represent WA during their hey day tho......ditto for Narkle, Baker et al

but no biggie mate.....you are a SD fan just merely supporting one of your own players.....a player you would watch more closely come match day than an opposing fan would do.....simply because they are watching their own players just as close.....it's ok to wear glasses mate....no matter how rose tinted or black/white they maybe.....just don't get all the subjective bias you guys come out with.......

as for attending the state game.....now Simmo and ROB aren't playing not much point really is there mate?....just won't be the same sadly....

Oh well my opinion is Stephen Dodd is a spud and from memory wasn't too flash last time he represented WA, gets towelled up most times he plays against SD too, probably why Gavin Brown (EF Backs coach) went white in the face when I informed him Swooper Geappen had decided to play on this year ..but just my opinion of course!!

He wasnt the only EF bloke to go all white in the face over Swooper kicking on this year mate ..apparently ol frosty over in Enzed went as white as a ghost!!

Ahahaha

not white as a ghost BH.....green with envy mate, because Geappen is a goalkicker every EF fan would love to have in their side.....but hey there's me offering another polar opposite response......just can't help myself I guess

....though I didn't realise you had to agree with a conversation or opinion to be allowed to contribute to it MO.....must be a SDFC behaviour incestually indoctrinated from birth.....scary....farkin scary!!

MarkOlsen wrote: i'd say based on the ladder positions the state coach has as many intersting views on players performances as Swans supporters.

I love comments like that MO, we will wait and see at seasons end how interesting his views are hey ? On last Saturdays effort, we are similarly placed in regards to form as last year, we have lost an extra 2 games of course with narrow losses to EF 3p, SD 7p. Last year we got over the line in the close ones, thats the only difference really !

if the state coach is talented enough to pick a state squad on future form then he can send me next weeks lotto numbers.
I would have thought it would be easier to pick a state team on current form but apologies if that is not the criteria.

One last time from me.
Well done to the Lee and Monaghan and all players, good win for the WAFL
Enough said