TOPIC:

For all you people that bag Harding the way he handled Wes Lammie hang your head in shame. If there was so much backing of Wes and disgruntlement with Harding do you think they would have played like they did against Perth. As for that thirds player at swan athletic stop listening to your demented friends who have been kicked out of the club.

Well said Kaos!

Lammie playing down in the SW footy league. Did a hammy in the first quarter down there.

This topic has become very emotive and some times irrational. Let me preface my remarks by saying my preferred option would be that Wes was still at the Club. If we dissect the season however there is no conclusive evidence that his omission has been overly detrimental to team performance. In the six games that he played Swans won three and lost three. They lost the first two games after he was unavailable when they were searching for a new structure without him. They have won four out of their last five with the only disappointing loss to West Perth when intensity was well down rather than a lack of ruck influence. I hope Wes overcomes his new injury and reconsiders his future at Swans.

Kaos wrote: For all you people that bag Harding the way he handled Wes Lammie hang your head in shame. If there was so much backing of Wes and disgruntlement with Harding do you think they would have played like they did against Perth. As for that thirds player at swan athletic stop listening to your demented friends who have been kicked out of the club.

I suppose you were referring to me their Greg, or should I say "Kaos" or are you Greg's brother in law (the one getting a gig with no football knowledge) not sure. I mentioned I had played thirds in the past but not currently. My knowlege comes from being a long time local member of Swans and closely connected copius amounts of people involved at the club. Good to see how you think of one of your main feeder clubs. But hey, it was Greg Harding who attempted to have all non selected Swans squad player play for Wesley Curtin (his old club) who are not in the SDFC zone. This is a disgrace.

I am getting confused, dont know if I should be addressing this post to Greg, Trent, whoever it was close to Harding to posted that. Not sure who the players kicked out of the club are at Swan Athletic, any former Swans players their left on their own accord and most have been invited back in recent years but decided against playing under the disfunctional (kicked out of Claremont) football department.

As for the big win, look at the players who dominated against Perth. At some point teams win games due to sheer amount of talent, regardless of who is coaching. Stop getting stressed knowing that with Swans fixing their financials quickly, paying out your mates contract for next year as they wish is becoming more and more likely for the board.

Moderators this post doesnt go against any of your guidelines but will probably be deleted for blatantly stating the truth at Swan who we all supoport

Sorry my fellow swan athletic member. I mean kicked out of swans not swan athletic. Just remember the rubbish you speak reflects on all at swan athletic. Stop being bitter because your mates got kicked out of swans for behaviour. I got on here because your making our good club sound very ordinary.

This is a forum where people discuss current events of all football clubs kaos. I spoke to people in the know and I posted limited information about that to ensure the other posters knew the real story.

I stated I am a member of both clubs. I dont know anyone who is bitter at Swan Athletic. And this kicked out of Swans business is unknown to me as mentioned all former swans players at Swan Ath I know of left on their own accord from there. And there isnt many on Ath;s list. I will go to their next home game and see if I can figure out who you are talking about.

Harding and Smart pushed legend Percy Johnson from the club recently by poor management, I guess he feeds people rubbish too and is bitter?

Are you saying everone who posts in a forum the words they hear from the inside is reflecting bad on the clubs they support? we may as well not have a forum.

My fellow member you fail to say that Percy has been sacked by 6 clubs in wafl and 1 in the afl. No problems with opinions but don't state them As fact

MacAttack wrote: This is a forum where people discuss current events of all football clubs kaos. I spoke to people in the know and I posted limited information about that to ensure the other posters knew the real story.

I stated I am a member of both clubs. I dont know anyone who is bitter at Swan Athletic. And this kicked out of Swans business is unknown to me as mentioned all former swans players at Swan Ath I know of left on their own accord from there. And there isnt many on Ath;s list. I will go to their next home game and see if I can figure out who you are talking about.

Harding and Smart pushed legend Percy Johnson from the club recently by poor management, I guess he feeds people rubbish too and is bitter?

Are you saying everone who posts in a forum the words they hear from the inside is reflecting bad on the clubs they support? we may as well not have a forum.

I'm bitter at Swan Athletic Mac but that goes way back to a colts game in 1992. Agree with what you've said here as long as we keep it reasonably polite. Forum is all about debate after all

Sorry Dirty Weekender I meant someone who is bitter who is at swan athletic now...rather than bitter at them. Agree all has been polite.

Kaos, I stated the facts of what I have been told from people who know. Then I expand on that with my opinion. I apologise you get flustered at your mate being shown up. Remind yourself this is a forum and nothing defamatory was said only the above.

As for Percy its very rich of you to attack a man of his age and standing. But as its obvious who you are friends with (or you are actually them) then its expected.