TOPIC:

he's the bloke that plays on from full back every time for WP, good for his stats every week

MarkOlsen wrote: he's the bloke that plays on from full back every time for WP, good for his stats every week

I'm sure that he's a solid enough player but Dobbo probably has more ability in his little pinky than the other fella has in his whole body,as WP found out last year as well as Griffin Logue who Dobbo turned inside out and was made to look like an outclassed ''AUS KICKER''but ability will only take you so far and his intensity and efforts this year have been very ordinary,but i suppose he was one of the dozen players that took the field on saturday that have had only around 20 games league experience,but Dobbo needs to address his mindset otherwise he'll end up in the ''could have should have category''

We went into the game with no match up for Kietel or Lourey. You could play the game 100 times we wouldn’t win. Having said that it was a spineless performance. If you can’t get motivated for a Derby in a shortened season then you need to get the broom out for next year. Players who will compete, run and tackle. Get that right then start to think finals etc.

Grump wrote: Kieran would be a good in but first in has to be Pebbles (Christian Amerduri) after his game on Saturday, with Gorter and North being close!

A mid and two defenders aren't going to help replace a forward if we drop Dobson and or Simpson.

(I'm sure I posted this last night, not sure why it went missing)

Mel wrote:

Grump wrote: Kieran would be a good in but first in has to be Pebbles (Christian Amerduri) after his game on Saturday, with Gorter and North being close!

A mid and two defenders aren't going to help replace a forward if we drop Dobson and or Simpson.

(I'm sure I posted this last night, not sure why it went missing)

I don't recall seeing the post but response would have been I am not suggesting we drop Dobson or Simpson but I would see Pebbles being a definite and the others as likely, who comes out or not is not upto me although I would suggest one wing needs to be fixed, a less than 50% effective possession rate is just not good enough, Hille on one and Pebbles on the side.

Agree Pebbles first in at least he will compete. After that most of the reserves are just good honest battlers. Probably Dean is the most talented along with Cooley and Cox. Two of those are unfit and one has just arrived at the club. Outs Kuek, Turner, Dobson, Simpson, Blee, Hille, Hooper, Hart and Hayden take your pick.

ROYAL 2019 wrote: Agree Pebbles first in at least he will compete. After that most of the reserves are just good honest battlers. Probably Dean is the most talented along with Cooley and Cox. Two of those are unfit and one has just arrived at the club. Outs Kuek, Turner, Dobson, Simpson, Blee, Hille, Hooper, Hart and Hayden take your pick.

Reds-yes, Purple - maybe, Hart and Hayden I would leave in but perhaps if ya had to drop one it would be Hayden just on the experience factor, Simpson needs to stay and Dobson is just ...... Cox is so unfit and overweight that he needs a couple of weeks to get even close, Cooley perhaps another game in the Ressies, he is a mouthy bloke with good skills so it will be interesting to see him in action against the Tiggers!

royallucky wrote:

Leedy wrote:

royallucky wrote:

Mel wrote:

SD351 wrote: In Dobbo’s defence what I could hear from the bench they wanted him deep forward and stay in the 50.

Not what the coach said to him after the game, in fact they wanted the opposite. He is totally out of shape and lazy. Needs to be dropped.

Our forward line is to slow at the moment. drop Dobson and replace him with Allsop who is in goal kicker form and willing to do the hard work on and off the field.

I agree 100% Mel.Allsop needs to come in,he has speed and energy and Dobbo was placed in the WAFL top 40 list in the W.Australian and i'm afraid he's read to much of his own publicity.

Sheezus, your kidding aren't you ! How can he get in that list and the likes of Blake Wilhelm be left out ???

Who the hell is Blake Wilhelm?

He's the bloke in the # 17 that carved you up on Saturday

MarkOlsen wrote: he's the bloke that plays on from full back every time for WP, good for his stats every week

Haha, your a funny man Ollie, try and tell me Wilhelm is an ordinary player in your response and that he wouldn't fit into your best 5 players at Swans let alone the 22.

Yep can’t drop them all Grump I agree. These are just guys I think struggle either for intensity, size, talent or speed at times. Quite often play well against poor opposition though.