TOPIC:

How would Subi supporters compare it to when Rhys Waters hit Brent Latch 5 or 6 years ago and knocked him out ?
Similar or worse ?

Good question MO...I'd say it was more like Shane Beros' cheap hit on Phil Read in 2008 which opened him up but hey...that was 12 years ago and not yesterday.

BC wrote: Yes we do Grump...I saw one bloke playing the ball and another taking a cheap shot which could have resulted in serious injury. As DG said, back in the 80's it would have been play on but I can guarantee Cahill would have been eating his next steak through a straw.

My oh My oobi doobi supporters talking strong arm tactics against a raw 20 game Royals rookie,i'm sure the late great J.K.Watts who used to refer to them as ''poor old SUBI''would be either turning or laughing in his grave!

Certainly must have purchased another glass house to live in at SFC.
Good to see the ex umpire put on another fitness and coaching masterclass

MarkOlsen wrote: Certainly must have purchased another glass house to live in at SFC.
Good to see the ex umpire put on another fitness and coaching masterclass

Lets not kid ourselves MO Subi has a Playing/Coach and has done for some years!

royallucky wrote:

BC wrote: Yes we do Grump...I saw one bloke playing the ball and another taking a cheap shot which could have resulted in serious injury. As DG said, back in the 80's it would have been play on but I can guarantee Cahill would have been eating his next steak through a straw.

My oh My oobi doobi supporters talking strong arm tactics against a raw 20 game Royals rookie,i'm sure the late great J.K.Watts who used to refer to them as ''poor old SUBI''would be either turning or laughing in his grave!

whether it's 20 games or 200 games it doesn't really matter when you intentionally whack a bloke to the side of the head....anyway, fortunately Newton recovered ok but Cahill can expect some time watching from the sidelines...but then again we're talking about the WAFC so who knows.

MarkOlsen wrote: How would Subi supporters compare it to when Rhys Waters hit Brent Latch 5 or 6 years ago and knocked him out ?
Similar or worse ?

Rod Willet's coward act late elbow high hit on the ball playing magician Phil Narkle after taking a mark thus ending a champion's career whilst that ordinary thug Willet played on was the worst I have seen in the last 40 years!

Settle down boys, every club has it's share of thugs, Mifka, Boucher, Neesham, Solin's, Bucknall, Swan, Campbell, Willet, Read, etc etc, it's a very long list depending on how far you want to go back in time, seems there's a new one to add to the list thats all.

Senior Seagull wrote: Settle down boys, every club has it's share of thugs, Mifka, Boucher, Neesham, Solin's, Bucknall, Swan, Campbell, Willet, Read, etc etc, it's a very long list depending on how far you want to go back in time, seems there's a new one to add to the list thats all.

I don't know about Mifka,we certainly never saw him as ''thug'',we regarded him as an antonym to that particular word.

BC the fact remains that you played very well with a relatively good team on the field. Well structured and your spread was frankly brilliant, the point you scored in the first quarter would qualify a point of the century, ball movement was superb.

Oh and I like you will defend players to the cows come home. have a good one!