TOPIC:

Carlton sacked Ratten two years ago to go after a proven big name coach. How has that gone for them?

Time For a Flag wrote: Carlton sacked Ratten two years ago to go after a proven big name coach. How has that gone for them?

I don't care what happens at other clubs, it's too late anyway the damage is done no way this club will be able to entice the supporters back they have lost this year.

This club will go through the motions until WestCoast move into Lathlain then they will bend over and join the alignment.

thefalconstrike wrote: This club is a joke, too reactive & nonot, proactive, sack him now & get someone in who the players respect & will play for. Show some leadership ip Atkins.

Spot on falcon strke, we are a joke. The suits have invested so much into their golden child and backed him to the hilt and they can't admit they got it horribly wong. McMahon is in his seventh year as a coach at this club and produced nothng at league level. Becuse he coached the colts to one grand final where they got pantsed, they thought he was a genius. Make no mistake, we are a bigger joke than Peel.

TFAF your continuous comparson with the likes of Bomber Thompson at Geelong, Ratten at Carlton and Hardick at Richmond is embarrassing. Give it away, McMahon is not a league coaches bootlace.

DD wrote:

thefalconstrike wrote: This club is a joke, too reactive & nonot, proactive, sack him now & get someone in who the players respect & will play for. Show some leadership ip Atkins.

Spot on falcon strke, ewe are a joke. The suits have invested so much into their golden child and backed him to the hilt and they can't admit they got it horribly wong. McMahon is in his seventh year as a coach at this club and produced nothng at league leve. Becuse he coached the colts to one grand final where they got pantsed, they tought he was a genius. Make no mistake, we are a biger joke than Peel.

TFAF your continuous comparson with the likes of Bomber Thompson at Geelong, Ratten at Carlton and Hardick at Richmond is embrrassing. Give it away, McMahon is not a league coaches bootlace.

Sorry DD, Closer to home - Swan District fans wanted Harding gone midway through last year.

Time For a Flag wrote: Carlton sacked Ratten two years ago to go after a proven big name coach. How has that gone for them?

You are joking...surely!

Are you happy with what McMahon has done so far?

It is he who is resonsible for the squad he has at his disposal and it is his job to get the players up for and during a game.
He is a poor tactician on match day.

He has failed on all fronts including recruiting the right personel to the club!!

What happens at any other footy club in Australia has absolutely no bearing on any changes the PFC make!!
But if you want to talk about impacts new coaches have on clubs then look no further than Port Adelaide!!!!!!! or the change at Claremont when they got rid of Kerr!!

Time For a Flag wrote:

DD wrote:

thefalconstrike ke ke wrote: This club is a joke, too reactive & nonot, proactive, sack him now & get someone in who the players respect & will play for. Show some leadership ip Atkins.

Spot on falcon strke, ewe are a joke. The suits have invested so much into their golden child and backed him to the hilt and they can't admit they got it horribly wong. McMahon is in his seventh year as a coach at this club and produced nothng at league leve. Becuse he coached the colts to one grand final where they got pantsed, they tought he was a genius. Make no mistake, we are a biger joke than Peel.

TFAF your continuous comparson with the likes of Bomber Thompson at Geelong, Ratten at Carlton and Hardick at Richmond is embrrassing. Give it away, McMahon is not a league coaches bootlace.

Sorry DD, Closer to home - Swan District fans wanted Harding gone midway through last year.

And he got them to second in 2012 and after they lost several exprienced players and unable to recuit in the off season due to the debt the club is in he has them sitting in equal top spot. Check mate.

Oh, and guess who coached SD to a one sided colts premiership against McMahon? And Harding played the game at the highest level. McMahon wasn't even up to WAFL league standard. He's a one trick pony with no feel for the game.

That's my point. Fans alway want a coaches head. Swans fans wanted Harding gone and look whats happened now. Just being devils advocate. A new coach hasn't worked the last 13 times for the club. Probably wont work next time by that statistic.

Time For a Flag wrote: That's my point. Fans alway want a coaches head. Swans fans wanted Harding gone and look whats happened now. Just being devils advocate. A new coach hasn't worked the last 13 times for the club. Probably wont work next time by that statistic.

No, you don't get the point. Harding had runs on the board and had one bad season. He was entitled to another and no doubt even with their player losses, if SD were sitting in our possie on the ladder, he would be as good as gone at the end of the season.

Time for DM to get on Seek and get back on the tools.

TFAF reminds me of the former Iraqi Foreign Minister.

Time For a Flag wrote: That's my point. Fans alway want a coaches head. Swans fans wanted Harding gone and look whats happened now. Just being devils advocate. A new coach hasn't worked the last 13 times for the club. Probably wont work next time by that statistic.

Well lets keep McMahon on and see how much more damage he can do shall we.
Not only will we continue to lose supporters but our top shelf players like Bevan will be out of here,is that what you want?

I didnt agree with his appointment and nothing has happened since to change my mind.

He's had plenty of time to at least show improvement in the team and he hasnt.
We are no closer to finals now than we were when he took over.