TOPIC:

When is this cheat going to give the medal back to the rightful owners, Mitchell and Cotchin.

Should be stripped post haste.

Also I find the fact his knobhead old man is still pontificating in the media after spending months trying to explain away Essendons cheating is nothing less than outrageous, he should be booted as well.

Just waiting for the next appeal to be upheld PN

Dirty Weekender wrote: Just waiting for the next appeal to be upheld PN

you never know DW.

It's an interesting situation for the AFL PN. Their own tribunal said that the evidence didn't stack up. If they take the Brownlow off Jobe are they saying they now no longer believe the findings of their own tribunal.

Peter North wrote: When is this cheat going to give the medal back to the rightful owners, Mitchell and Cotchin.

Check the criteria for the voting of the BROWNLOW Medal. It NEVER mentions the word FAIREST. Just the BEST.

Dirty Weekender wrote: It's an interesting situation for the AFL PN. Their own tribunal said that the evidence didn't stack up. If they take the Brownlow off Jobe are they saying they now no longer believe the findings of their own tribunal.

reminds me of a political party doing a review on their own party, not surprisingly a few minor problems ( just to deflect the cynics out there), but generally "all good". AFL answerable to themselves in the running of the game etc, only when a TRULY independant organisation comes along that they get "sprung!".

Leather Stops wrote:

Peter North wrote: When is this cheat going to give the medal back to the rightful owners, Mitchell and Cotchin.

Check the criteria for the voting of the BROWNLOW Medal. It NEVER mentions the word FAIREST. Just the BEST.

I know your not the smartest person going around, but what normally happens when you get done for drug cheating is that you lose all awards, medals etc ala Marrion Jones Ben Johnson.

Leather Stops wrote:

Peter North wrote: When is this cheat going to give the medal back to the rightful owners, Mitchell and Cotchin.

Check the criteria for the voting of the BROWNLOW Medal. It NEVER mentions the word FAIREST. Just the BEST.

Uhmm, since when? If that were the case suspended players would be eligible.

Leather Stops wrote:

Peter North wrote: When is this cheat going to give the medal back to the rightful owners, Mitchell and Cotchin.

Check the criteria for the voting of the BROWNLOW Medal. It NEVER mentions the word FAIREST. Just the BEST.

Yeah that must be why so many suspended players win medals.