TOPIC:

Rookie draft wrote: What’s the track record of Subiaco premiership coaches that have tried their hand in the AFL........

Pretty average from memory.. Schofield will be no different. He has a number of flaws in his personality that are exposed under pressure. The problem so far is he hasn’t been under pressure enough as he has had the best list and an endless supply of funds and incentives to ensure success.

He was badly exposed in and after the last 2 GFs. His conduct should have been sanctioned by Subi admin and WAFC but they were too weak.

There’s no way he could go to Freo given the criticism he’s unloaded on the Freo/Peel alignment. Then again the guys morals are in the gutter so perhaps he would. Double standards?

Could you elaborate the point about being badly exposed in and after the GF? Apologies I don't understand.

ArkRoyal wrote: Shark 58: that is true -- if you are a good coach and you have a good side, all things being equal, you should win the flag.

Coaches whom have won flags with weakish sides in recent times are:

Brad Smith
John Todd a
Ken Armstrong
Haydn Bunton
Bill Monaghan
Ken Judge


Therefore, at the other end of the equation I would not rate the following:

Mal Brown
Graham Moss

When did Brad Smith recently coach a side let alone a weakish side to a flag!

I know he coached the mighty blue and whites to a flag in1979 but that was not recent nor could you call a side with Peake, D.Green, Purser, Sewell, Lester-Smith, Judge, Taylor, Buhagiar weakish.

Rookie draft wrote: What’s the track record of Subiaco premiership coaches that have tried their hand in the AFL........

Pretty average from memory.. Schofield will be no different. He has a number of flaws in his personality that are exposed under pressure. The problem so far is he hasn’t been under pressure enough as he has had the best list and an endless supply of funds and incentives to ensure success.

He was badly exposed in and after the last 2 GFs. His conduct should have been sanctioned by Subi admin and WAFC but they were too weak.

There’s no way he could go to Freo given the criticism he’s unloaded on the Freo/Peel alignment. Then again the guys morals are in the gutter so perhaps he would. Double standards?

Piss off back to Centrelink you flog.

Lol BC you remind me of Schofield...........put a bit of heat on and you melt like butter.

Ti Em wrote:

Rookie draft wrote: What’s the track record of Subiaco premiership coaches that have tried their hand in the AFL........

Pretty average from memory.. Schofield will be no different. He has a number of flaws in his personality that are exposed under pressure. The problem so far is he hasn’t been under pressure enough as he has had the best list and an endless supply of funds and incentives to ensure success.

He was badly exposed in and after the last 2 GFs. His conduct should have been sanctioned by Subi admin and WAFC but they were too weak.

There’s no way he could go to Freo given the criticism he’s unloaded on the Freo/Peel alignment. Then again the guys morals are in the gutter so perhaps he would. Double standards?

Could you elaborate the point about being badly exposed in and after the GF? Apologies I don't understand.

In - out coached. After - poor body language, inappropriate comments and stormed off the ground during presentation.

Rookie draft wrote: Lol BC you remind me of Schofield...........put a bit of heat on and you melt like butter.

I am by no means a fan of BC nor his WAFL club of Subiaco. I think that when you exercise your prerogative as the Peel moderator and exorcise a post from that thread you do it in the context of your posts contained within this thread.

42...as I'm sure you well know RD has never maintained the same standards when moderating and posting. Even on the FART thread he/she/it regularly posts things which are designed to shit stir but deletes anything even remotely disingenuous or critical towards FART. So his slanderous comments towards Schofield are not surprising.

Rookie draft wrote:

Ti Em wrote:

Rookie draft wrote: What’s the track record of Subiaco premiership coaches that have tried their hand in the AFL........

Pretty average from memory.. Schofield will be no different. He has a number of flaws in his personality that are exposed under pressure. The problem so far is he hasn’t been under pressure enough as he has had the best list and an endless supply of funds and incentives to ensure success.


He was badly exposed in and after the last 2 GFs. His conduct should have been sanctioned by Subi admin and WAFC but they were too weak.

There’s no way he could go to Freo given the criticism he’s unloaded on the Freo/Peel alignment. Then again the guys morals are in the gutter so perhaps he would. Double standards?

Could you elaborate the point about being badly exposed in and after the GF? Apologies I don't understand.

In - out coached. After - poor body language, inappropriate comments and stormed off the ground during presentation.

Was he outcoached? I know Peel improved dramatically come finals time by bringing alot of Dockers in. I forget the number - you probably have a better idea of the number. Perhaps that is what tipped the scale against them? I know Subiaco's kicking for goals cost them too.
With respect to his behaviour afterwards I think it is harsh to criticize body language. Refresh me, what where the comments that were so objectionable?

Rookie draft wrote: Lol BC you remind me of Schofield...........put a bit of heat on and you melt like butter.

...and you remind me of Cam Shepherd...a delusional apologist for a blood sucking AFL club.

Ti Em wrote:

ArkRoyal wrote: Shark 58: that is true -- if you are a good coach and you have a good side, all things being equal, you should win the flag.

Coaches whom have won flags with weakish sides in recent times are:

Brad Smith
John Todd a
Ken Armstrong
Haydn Bunton
Bill Monaghan
Ken Judge


Therefore, at the other end of the equation I would not rate the following:

Mal Brown
Graham Moss

When did Brad Smith recently coach a side let alone a weakish side to a flag!

I know he coached the mighty blue and whites to a flag in1979 but that was not recent nor could you call a side with Peake, D.Green, Purser, Sewell, Lester-Smith, Judge, Taylor, Buhagiar weakish.

I guess Ark means the likes Mountain, McKay, Bauskis, Haddow and Barrett were better Ti Em...LOL