TOPIC:

Footyfan2 wrote: Don’t forget EF missed the finals by 1 game in 2016. Big wins included smashing Subiaco by 80 points away from home, also belting Souths at Fremantle oval in the Derby. (Last time EF won a Derby).
Bring on 2017 they lost Peake, O’Brien, James Bristow early in season and never recovered. (Pushed a rampaging Subiaco mid season with scores level at 3 quarter time). Marsh, Hampson, Cuneo, Jupp, T Bristow missed games to injury....... then the board decided Rob needed time to develop this squad and extended his contract by a year. 2018 was tough due to injuries a weak board who caved into public consensus and removed Rob.

I thought Rob decided not to renew an option on his contract to continue on for 2019 - it was for the best for all parties that he went anyway because he was getting nothing from the players and no doubt sick of coaching a side getting severely pumped most weekends.

Custodian wrote: Perhaps you could ask some of your mates like DD et al the same question with regards to comments about the EFFC.

You ask him Custy and while you are about ask Freez, KCEF, Ti Em et al

Cesspit wrote:

Freezin wrote: DD...mate happy to talk Monaghan after a few year of coaching EF...not just after one season....geez you would of sacked Earl way before 2019 mate going on your logic....Monaghan had the same number of wins in one season that Wiley achieved in 2 seasons with the same squad.....at least give Bill another couple of seasons before writing him off....Earl is into his 6 or 7th season at Perth....no finals footy....look in your own back yard for coaching mediocrity before peering over the fence into other back yards and judging....Wiley was 5/2 in 2016 before the rot set in...and he had no ability what so ever to arrest it....despite having up to 8-10 ex AFL listed guys on his books....great footballer....just a very ordinary head coach....at least have the footy nous to judge Monaghan after a couple of seasons at EF....his on field record at WP over ten years stacks up...more so than Earl's and Wiley's....last finals action Earl's coaching has seen was 2002....with EF....LOL.....would of been 2019 , but 22 guys choked in last couple minutes of the game to ruin it for him....poor fella.....but hey your benchmark for success is somewhat clouded compared to the rest of us.....

Wiley had the same squad did he.
Oh ok if you don’t include Boekhurst, Manning, Davies and Stranidica, to name a few.

No, he had:

Brock O’Brien
McNamara
Watson
J.Bristow
Peake
J.Marsh
Hampson

Over his journey. Pretty handy names there

smokey wrote:

Custodian wrote: Perhaps you could ask some of your mates like DD et al the same question with regards to comments about the EFFC.

You ask him Custy and while you are about ask Freez, KCEF, Ti Em et al[/quote

Well I promise to play nice from now onwards will only say nice things about Mineral Resources.

Stand the Test wrote: You can overanalyse stuff a bit.

Wiley clearly a useless coach, why anyone thought it would be any different following him being a floppo at PFC and then running around after shithouse for twenty years a bit silly.

EF have been useless for twenty years.

Earl a v poor coach, his record tells us that.

PFC have been useless for 40 years.

We have better facilities, big deal.

We beat you at home, you beat us at home. How exciting.

There is no obvious reason why either of us would improve dramatically in 2020, just have to hope other teams go worse.

But PFC not guilty of fucking up Cody leggett’s career for a year.

That was ALL ef.

No leauge flags this millennium for either club with only 2 WAFL league GF appearences, 1 Foxtel cup GF, a shoot themselves in the foot Prelim in 2014 and a grand total of 5 finals campaigns in that time between them. Lets hope both at the least make the 5 this year.

Stand the Test wrote:

Ti Em wrote:

Stand the Test wrote: You can overanalyse stuff a bit.

Wiley clearly a useless coach, why anyone thought it would be any different following him being a floppo at PFC and then running around after shithouse for twenty years a bit silly.

EF have been useless for twenty years.

Earl a v poor coach, his record tells us that.

PFC have been useless for 40 years.

We have better facilities, big deal.

We beat you at home, you beat us at home. How exciting.

There is no obvious reason why either of us would improve dramatically in 2020, just have to hope other teams go worse.

But PFC not guilty of fucking up Cody leggett’s career for a year.

That was ALL ef.

No leauge flags this millennium for either club with only 2 WAFL league GF appearences, 1 Foxtel cup GF, a shoot themselves in the foot Prelim in 2014 and a grand total of 5 finals campaigns in that time between them. Lets hope both at the least make the 5 this year.

Classic example of overanalysing Dr Meaningless Stats.

Hardly EFFCs fault that your best player wants to play for them now is it? And easy on the name calling - you will upset Smokey.

Stand the Test wrote: You can overanalyse stuff a bit.

Very true

Wiley clearly a useless coach, why anyone thought it would be any different following him being a floppo at PFC and then running around after shithouse for twenty years a bit silly.

On the money again

EF have been useless for twenty years.

Two GF....five finals series and 3 wooden spoons....

Earl a v poor coach, his record tells us that.

Poor at Perth 0 finals and 3 wooden spoons in 6-7 years

Not so at EF 1 finals series in 2 years of coaching....50/50

PFC have been useless for 40 years.
Goes with out saying

We have better facilities, big deal.

Very true way better facilities

We beat you at home, you beat us at home. How exciting.

Last 20 years EF 20 Perth 4 at EF oval
Perth 9 EF 12 at Lathlain...32 / 13 head to head in last 20 years...yep not exciting reading for a Perth fan


There is no obvious reason why either of us would improve dramatically in 2020, just have to hope other teams go worse.

Be great to see both teams make the finals

But PFC not guilty of fucking up Cody leggett’s career for a year.

Perth are guilty as fuck with no finals and 3 wooden spoons during Cody's Perth career...can see why he wants to leave

That was ALL ef.

Hasn't played for EF...so not sure what you mean....let's judge him after his first couple of seasons at EF

I guess facts / stats help differentiate which opinions are deluded and not so deluded.

smokey wrote:

Custodian wrote: Perhaps you could ask some of your mates like DD et al the same question with regards to comments about the EFFC.

You ask him Custy and while you are about ask Freez, KCEF, Ti Em et al

Ask me what Smokester?.

DD wrote: Just hope someone at the dump has called in a structural engineer to test the structural integrity of the joint. Everytime I drive passed I see another crack. Hopefully it doesn't collapse, not on an away team anyway.

are you a one eyed rat or what
your decrepit looking building you call home looks like something from the addams family especially inside
at least west coast are helping out in some capacity well on the outside anyway

smokey wrote: Good luck KC....
And TE, I don’t understand why you and your cohorts keep putting PFC down continually.
You lot go far beyond friendly banter and then call it piss-take.

take the blinkers of smokey for f sake