TOPIC:

Has anyone edited their tips in this competition and not had them recognised? I edited my tips last week on Saturday morning to the same tips i made in Oos's tipping comp and i got 4 winners but Ozfooty tipping comp shows me as tipping just 2 winners (which were my original tips). It took 3 emails to Footytips.com to get a response and they said sorry we don't have any evidence of editing your tips. I checked the tips after i edited them and it displayed my changes. I have given them the link to Oos's tipping comp as proof but got no response. I use the same name under both comps. Pretty piss poor.

George can you follow up on this please?

Johnno never had a problem in this area. I did run a comp on ESPN last year and never happened. They got the results wrong once but fixed pretty quick.
Possibly your error. When you went into Tipping and selected the round and clicked on Edit tips after you changed them did you click on SUBMIT down the bottom? If you didnt they would not change from you previous tips.

George can change the ladder being admin but not recommended as it could start a landslide where people would be saying their tips were wrong etc. Not saying this is what you are doing as you appear genuine.

Its not piss poor if you made the error. It happens. Had a look at your tips from round 8 and it could of gone the other way with a couple of the games. Now that would of been a bonus for you. If your still unhappy suggest you give OZFOOTY comp a miss and just stick to Birds comp?

Cardy wrote: Johnno never had a problem in this area. I did run a comp on ESPN last year and never happened. They got the results wrong once but fixed pretty quick.
Possibly your error. When you went into Tipping and selected the round and clicked on Edit tips after you changed them did you click on SUBMIT down the bottom? If you didnt they would not change from you previous tips.

George can change the ladder being admin but not recommended as it could start a landslide where people would be saying their tips were wrong etc. Not saying this is what you are doing as you appear genuine.

Its not piss poor if you made the error. It happens. Had a look at your tips from round 8 and it could of gone the other way with a couple of the games. Now that would of been a bonus for you. If your still unhappy suggest you give OZFOOTY comp a miss and just stick to Birds comp?

Shouldn't have tipped against the Falcons anyway !

Johnno I went into the Tipping page and edited my tips for round 9 Submitted them and went back they had changed. I then edited them again to my original picks , Submitted them and they changed back. So doesnt appear to be a problem with the programme and never heard of one.

Cardy wrote: Johnno never had a problem in this area. I did run a comp on ESPN last year and never happened. They got the results wrong once but fixed pretty quick.
Possibly your error. When you went into Tipping and selected the round and clicked on Edit tips after you changed them did you click on SUBMIT down the bottom? If you didnt they would not change from you previous tips.

George can change the ladder being admin but not recommended as it could start a landslide where people would be saying their tips were wrong etc. Not saying this is what you are doing as you appear genuine.

Its not piss poor if you made the error. It happens. Had a look at your tips from round 8 and it could of gone the other way with a couple of the games. Now that would of been a bonus for you. If your still unhappy suggest you give OZFOOTY comp a miss and just stick to Birds comp?

Yes I did, it then showed my edited tips and also i tipped Peel to win by 10 points, they won by 9. I have proof to back it up, if I didn't tip anywhere else then yes it's here say. Why would i tip differently for the same league? What is the point of having an edit feature if it doesn't work? I am sure if they got someone to have a look in the back office of the program it would show i tried but at their end perhaps it didn't go through successfully for some reason.

Cardy wrote: Johnno I went into the Tipping page and edited my tips for round 9 Submitted them and went back they had changed. I then edited them again to my original picks , Submitted them and they changed back. So doesnt appear to be a problem with the programme and never heard of one.

I know Cardy, i have since done the same thing 3 times on the AFL tipping comp and it works fine. But like i said, it appeared to work fine when i did it but after the games it showed my original tips. I sent them feedback straight away but got no response until a third attempt.

Johnno wrote:

Cardy wrote: Johnno I went into the Tipping page and edited my tips for round 9 Submitted them and went back they had changed. I then edited them again to my original picks , Submitted them and they changed back. So doesnt appear to be a problem with the programme and never heard of one.

I know Cardy, i have since done the same thing 3 times on the AFL tipping comp and it works fine. But like i said, it appeared to work fine when i did it but after the games it showed my original tips. I sent them feedback straight away but got no response until a third attempt.

Could of been a computer glitch at the time and when you submitted the new tips it didnt respond. Bloody Computers Thanks for the info anyway will check later if I change my tips to make sure it is done. I suppose at the end of the day it could actually work in your favour.. Admins decision but sounds like you have a genuine complaint. Maybe as a act of good faith they could allow a one off and change your ladder.. Their call.

So far no joy Cardy but I've emailed George. They said they can't recognise a comp that has nothing to do with Footytips.com. They said if I edit my tips in future to email or print them off as proof. I said that's not helpful advice after the event and that really shouldn't be necessary. If it didn't show my edited tips after I submitted them I could have done something along those lines. I have edited tips before without a problem. As you can see there were not too many who tipped 4 winners which makes a significant difference.

George or Mike the OZFOOTY tipping comp is it going to include the Finals or just the regular season. Doggy was interested (being the leader) I am dead and buried.

It obviously cant include the GF as that is the Prize

just home and away