TOPIC:

Looks like the even up rule is going to be implemented in c4 this year. Interested to hear what people think of this idea.

The step from the e grades to c4 has been one that most clubs have struggled with. Since 2011 only 2 clubs (Nollamara and Rossmoyne) have been able to maintain a 2nd side beyond a year or 2 since making the move up. The positive will be that clubs will be encouraged to field a 2nd side, move out of e grade and stop beating up on clubs 3rd or below sides.
It should also see a higher standard of league game without guys in these clubs who struggle for numbers doubling up.

On the flipside, I can see clubs like Osborne Park, Jandakot and kwinana with good numbers or even 3rd sides being at a disadvantage. Having 66+ players to pick from and potentially having 7 have to sit on the bench in your 23-44th player bracket would no doubt be frustrating when you're lining up against 15 players.

Curious to hear people's thoughts on this.
Interesting to note that c4 will be a 12 team comp this year. Has this initiative been pushed by these clubs looking to come up?

If this is the case it is a slippery slope?

This happens in a Colts and for clubs doing this every week it won't take long for a few injuries, work commitments etc to take their toll.

Much like the Colts the teams usually end up doubling up and eventually forfeiting.

It's a hard one as it can be seen as making an exception to get a club moving up to two sides but can also be costly.

This is only my opinion from experience but open to hear the pros and cons.