TOPIC:

Leather Stops wrote:

ooollllrrrrrry2 wrote:

ArkRoyal wrote: oool -- it was picked in 2006 or so -- if you were to pick it now, you wold also be able to pick Franklin.

He would slot in pretty easily.

This team was for the 20th Century (1900-1999) & therefore Adam Goodes should NOT be eligible as his first AFL season was in 1999.
A Kid from South Bunbury namely Syd Jackson played in TWO Carlton premierships & deserves a spot.

Syd Jackson would be on the centre line I would have thought.
Hated him as a kid.
During the 60s he used to star for EP against the DEES.
Saw him kick the goal of the 20th century one day at Lathlain.
Ran around about 10 DEES on a run that started on the half backline.
19,000 at Lathlain that day, about 1968 I think.
Great player.

Leather Stops wrote:

ooollllrrrrrry2 wrote:

ArkRoyal wrote: oool -- it was picked in 2006 or so -- if you were to pick it now, you wold also be able to pick Franklin.

He would slot in pretty easily.

This team was for the 20th Century (1900-1999) & therefore Adam Goodes should NOT be eligible as his first AFL season was in 1999.
A Kid from South Bunbury namely Syd Jackson played in TWO Carlton premierships & deserves a spot.

He is, on a half forward flank.

Oooll quite surprised the golden boy isn't there.....Graham Kickett was a devastating player off a HFF for EF back in his day....

Freezin wrote: Oooll quite surprised the golden boy isn't there.....Graham Kickett was a devastating player
off a HFF for EF back in his day....

Kevin Taylor's 1979 season alone should have had him in there somewhere 102 goals as a forward pocket/rover is simply astonishing, still had a very good career in the 1980s as well.

Kieth+Phil Narkle are both straight up selectors. Both gun footballers and both would of been superstars in modern day AFL.

Freezin wrote: Oooll quite surprised the golden boy isn't there.....Graham Kickett was a devastating player off a HFF for EF back in his day....

Well known for role coming off the bench in the well remembered Southerner pumping of 79 mate.

The other thing they about Keith Narkle is that he played 254 games, kicking a goal a game, sometimes in a weak side.
In regards to Phil, whom definitely played in a rubbish side, all his stats are comparable to Greg Burns, one of his team mates in those years at the club..