TOPIC:

Dirty Weekender wrote: How much did Robbo end up agreeing to play for as a matter of interest??? My mail was that he was demanding a figure just under 1/5 of the entire salary cap at Swans hence the move to Subi. Do the maths just on him and Twomey alone and you gotta wonder how Subi can squeeze the rest of the squad in considering many are now premiership players. No offence intended. I liked watching Robbo play and am sure you are getting your money's worth at Subi as you have been with Twomey.

He's playing for love...I'm sure the souths boys will be happy to tell you all about how that works..

My prediction in the thread was that the top three from last year wouldn't change mate

I'd be happy to tell you about love if it were a fact instead of myth too by the way

Southerner wrote: My prediction in the thread was that the top three from last year wouldn't change mate

I'd be happy to tell you about love if it were a fact instead of myth too by the way

Good call, most including me thought we would struggle because of our losses.

Maybe - it isn't over yet

We were investigated (as were some players implicated by bullshit rumours ) at least once that I know of , that resulted in Chris Bossong getting Perth nabbed

Yep far from over yet

jonnyboy wrote:

Leedy wrote:

DG wrote:

Beasley Hutton wrote: A good start by Townsend but still some more questions to be asked in my book?
How are Joel Latham & Mitchell McPhee both picked up from WP only listed as 1 point players whilst Slater & Wityk picked up by SD from WART are worth 2 points each?
Despite this deliberate misuse of the top up rule $ubi may well still be over the points cap if the WAFC check the players details a little bit more carefully and or Slater & Wityk's points come down to 1 either either!

Well Beas I'd say that's because your two boys played league games with the ferals whilst our boys only played magoo's with joondy before crossing over...

Both played a bit of League with us DG ! Same shit different bucket for mine, BH is spot on, look forward to hearing this excuse from the knob ticklers at the WAFC

check your facts leedy. neither of the 2 picked up by subi have played league for west perth. reserves or colts only.

Which 2 WP players are you talking about JB ? I can categorically tell you that Latham, Stockley, Lockyer and McPhee played league footy for WP (McPhee a Foxtel Cup game) which counts towards a league game.

DG wrote:

Southerner wrote: What a farce

How can "loopholes" exist in a so-called fairness & equality system ???

You cannot tell me Subi didn't know recuiting Robinson popped the cap - they knew full well any maximum value rating placed on Robinson smashed it

Greed

Not greed mate just smart business. Most of our recruits this season have a history of injury problems so any of them could go down any time, as we have already seen with Menegola missing half the season. We lost a lot of good players from last season, where did you have us to finish at the start of the year?

DG and all on this thread,

DG's above words are what myself and Swandog have been preaching since last year regarding the salary cap points, hence $alaryaco used a number of times. Players from Subi seemed to have mystery injuries on a rotational basis last year and its continued on this year, you don't need to be a Rhode scholar. I call it cheating, from a $subi supporters perspective, I can lend weight to good management as they are getting away with it. As BH has already mentioned, the simple, basic, rudimentary error of the Mitch McPhee debacle is astounding, its cut and dry that he has played league footy

Leedy wrote:

DG wrote:

Southerner wrote: What a farce

How can "loopholes" exist in a so-called fairness & equality system ???

You cannot tell me Subi didn't know recuiting Robinson popped the cap - they knew full well any maximum value rating placed on Robinson smashed it

Greed

Not greed mate just smart business. Most of our recruits this season have a history of injury problems so any of them could go down any time, as we have already seen with Menegola missing half the season. We lost a lot of good players from last season, where did you have us to finish at the start of the year?

DG and all on this thread,

DG's above words are what myself and Swandog have been preaching since last year regarding the salary cap points, hence $alaryaco used a number of times. Players from Subi seemed to have mystery injuries on a rotational basis last year and its continued on this year, you don't need to be a Rhode scholar. I call it cheating, from a $subi supporters perspective, I can lend weight to good management as they are getting away with it. As BH has already mentioned, the simple, basic, rudimentary error of the Mitch McPhee debacle is astounding, its cut and dry that he has played league footy

Not too sure how that works mate as we look to be at almost full strength for tomorrow apart from Stockley & a few 1 pointers. Are you suggesting Stockley hasn't done his knee?

DG wrote:

Leedy wrote:

DG wrote:

Southerner wrote: What a farce

How can "loopholes" exist in a so-called fairness & equality system ???

You cannot tell me Subi didn't know recuiting Robinson popped the cap - they knew full well any maximum value rating placed on Robinson smashed it

Greed

Not greed mate just smart business. Most of our recruits this season have a history of injury problems so any of them could go down any time, as we have already seen with Menegola missing half the season. We lost a lot of good players from last season, where did you have us to finish at the start of the year?

DG and all on this thread,

DG's above words are what myself and Swandog have been preaching since last year regarding the salary cap points, hence $alaryaco used a number of times. Players from Subi seemed to have mystery injuries on a rotational basis last year and its continued on this year, you don't need to be a Rhode scholar. I call it cheating, from a $subi supporters perspective, I can lend weight to good management as they are getting away with it. As BH has already mentioned, the simple, basic, rudimentary error of the Mitch McPhee debacle is astounding, its cut and dry that he has played league footy

Not too sure how that works mate as we look to be at almost full strength for tomorrow apart from Stockley & a few 1 pointers. Are you suggesting Stockley hasn't done his knee?

The article in Saturdays West should clear it up, re- Twomeys "foot" injury keeping him out for 2 weeks

.