TOPIC:

This guy is such a brilliant player and yet he sometimes just has a complete 'Brain Fade' ( his words not mine) like he did today with that trip. Completely bamboozles me

mikeh wrote: This guy is such a brilliant player and yet he sometimes just has a complete 'Brain Fade' ( his words not mine) like he did today with that trip. Completely bamboozles me

Will be a fine or nothing to see.

If we go by the precedent set this year he will cop a fine, anyway he will will be mvp this year which is regarded more highly by players not whether you get more possessions on the day which seems to be the way umpires award votes anyway that's why key position players don't get the votes.

Lol it's been a national comp for how many years and the award is still named after a Victorian who gives a **** about Chas.

swan42 wrote:

mikeh wrote: This guy is such a brilliant player and yet he sometimes just has a complete 'Brain Fade' ( his words not mine) like he did today with that trip. Completely bamboozles me

Will be a fine or nothing to see.

If he is found guilty and fined he will be ineligible for the Brownlow. Just a pity because I reckon he would be streets in front already

mikeh wrote:

swan42 wrote:

mikeh wrote: This guy is such a brilliant player and yet he sometimes just has a complete 'Brain Fade' ( his words not mine) like he did today with that trip. Completely bamboozles me

Will be a fine or nothing to see.

If he is found guilty and fined he will be ineligible for the Brownlow. Just a pity because I reckon he would be streets in front already

They have changed the rules; a fine does not make you ineligible for the VFL F&B medal Mikeh.

swan42 wrote:

mikeh wrote:

swan42 wrote:

mikeh wrote: This guy is such a brilliant player and yet he sometimes just has a complete 'Brain Fade' ( his words not mine) like he did today with that trip. Completely bamboozles me

Will be a fine or nothing to see.

If he is found guilty and fined he will be ineligible for the Brownlow. Just a pity because I reckon he would be streets in front already

They have changed the rules; a fine does not make you ineligible for the VFL F&B medal Mikeh.

Thanks Swan42 didn't realise that so maybe he hasnt thrown it away after all

swan42 wrote:

mikeh wrote:

swan42 wrote:

mikeh wrote: This guy is such a brilliant player and yet he sometimes just has a complete 'Brain Fade' ( his words not mine) like he did today with that trip. Completely bamboozles me

Will be a fine or nothing to see.

If he is found guilty and fined he will be ineligible for the Brownlow. Just a pity because I reckon he would be streets in front already

They have changed the rules; a fine does not make you ineligible for the VFL F&B medal Mikeh.

42 out of interest what did you think of the umpiring in the Fremantle vs Footscray game?
26 free kicks to 11 in a game Freo were never behind in.

Beasley Hutton wrote:

swan42 wrote:

mikeh wrote:

swan42 wrote:

mikeh wrote: This guy is such a brilliant player and yet he sometimes just has a complete 'Brain Fade' ( his words not mine) like he did today with that trip. Completely bamboozles me

Will be a fine or nothing to see.

If he is found guilty and fined he will be ineligible for the Brownlow. Just a pity because I reckon he would be streets in front already

They have changed the rules; a fine does not make you ineligible for the VFL F&B medal Mikeh.

42 out of interest what did you think of the umpiring in the Fremantle vs Footscray game?
26 free kicks to 11 in a game Freo were never behind in.

Didn't watch much of the game. Was it Freo with the 26 frees for or did they get 11 frees?

Footscray got 26, Fremantle got 11.

Beasley Hutton wrote: Footscray got 26, Fremantle got 11.

Not completely surprising BH. As I said our criticism of the WAFL umpires is equally applicable to the AFL ones.