TOPIC:

Michael Sinclair for me ahead of Fraser. The guy is a superstar and has served the club for a long time, fought well out of his division and been amazing. Also think his leadership credentials have grown over recent years. No brainer for me

Baseline wrote: Michael Sinclair for me ahead of Fraser. The guy is a superstar and has served the club for a long time, fought well out of his division and been amazing. Also think his leadership credentials have grown over recent years. No brainer for me

Yep I agree

I think McInnes. I have enormous respect for Sinclair as a player and a person, but he's a quiet character. McInnes is more likely to be more vocal in terms of demanding high standards from his team mates.

I favour Fraser. No brainer for me.

It’s a hard one. I think McInnes is the man but I’m not sure we should reward him with the captaincy when he chose to play for WCE reserves over us in 2019. Either will do a good job. I just don’t want Sinclair’s game to suffer. I thought he wasn’t at his usual top last year. Still good but not outstanding. Whether that was the captaincy we don’t know.

Cess, Fraser played against us in an East Perth jumper when he was on WCE list. When he was delisted he stayed with the Eagles to play in their WAFL side along side Grey and Fisher. Yeah, that was disappointing but it was only one season. I would not hold that against him.
Then last year the three of them came to us on loan. They all bought into our programme and were possibly the reason we played finals by which time Fraser at least said he was glad to be a Demon again and committed to us and won the Butcher Medal. Grey and Fisher adopted the club and stayed with us. He now is a very important player for us and a key to our attempt to go at least one better than 2020 and, hopefully further
Sinclair would walk into any other WAFL club. A great player but injury prone. He keeps the backline a solid no nonsense group. I think that he is best suited to concentrate on that.
Yep, it is Fraser for mine.

Firstly I don't think we should be giving Yeo a hard time for his DJ set at the South Freo game. Many people liked it and they were trying to promote the club. Next time no music while play is on though please.
Back to the question at hand - captain has to be Sinclair. He lead the team well last year and has been very loyal to the club. Fraser and Masto to Vice Captain. I would also like to see FISHER in the leadership group - I like the cut of his jib, there is a bit of mongrel about him.

PD1899 wrote: Firstly I don't think we should be giving Yeo a hard time for his DJ set at the South Freo game. Many people liked it and they were trying to promote the club. Next time no music while play is on though please.
Back to the question at hand - captain has to be Sinclair. He lead the team well last year and has been very loyal to the club. Fraser and Masto to Vice Captain. I would also like to see Fletcher in the leadership group - I like the cut of his jib, there is a bit of mongrel about him.

Fletcher?

Stand the Test wrote: Surely it’s got to be the Big Mac. Who are you walking taller with, the big guy or the DJ?

Corey’s been ok but injury prone and surely Frase the man. He never misses a game, has finally come across to the D’s and never stops running, presenting, trying.

And if he is injured he’d probably be around huddle at 3/4 time rather than spinning discs for the chicks.

DJ Yo Yo Yo Yo Yooooo. No.

This was a club decision where they tried to bring some more people through the gates and making the most of the twilight fixture against SF by creating a party atmosphere. They had different alcoholic drinks which I think Masto had a hand in organising and they were going to have meals by Laikia but that fell through due to the deal in place with HJ's.

Bit unfair just to have a crack at Yeo, who as captain was helping out with a function the club wanted to put on.

As it turns out, with the result of the game going in our favour and the club breaking its finals drought of 23 years and the resulting atmosphere around the club that night, you'd say that this proved to be a successful marketing ploy by the club.

100% Right AFL.

Anyway all would be good in there own way.

Yeo a great face of the club and excellent communicator. Continuity another factor and allows Sinners to focus on his brilliant game without extra responsibility.

Sinners has been through thick and thin with the club universally liked has always stepped in to fill the Captaincy role.

Frazer - I reckon loves the club. I saw him come and watch us when he was aligned with EP and he looked to feel bad for our loss on that day. Has the most presence on the field.

I will be happy with any of the 3