TOPIC:

swan42 wrote:

Unholytugboat wrote:

Tiger Tales wrote:

swan42 wrote:

Tiger Tales wrote:

swan42 wrote:

Tiger Tales wrote:

swan42 wrote:

Tiger Tales wrote: Geez Swan42 hardly a surprise that you want to refer every single conversation back to host club alignment. To be honest your comments have become boring.

It's time for Ross to go because the Dockers have failed to adapt their game plan which allows them to kick enough goals to win games. Are the Dockers in a better position now than when Ross arrived? No they are not.

Frankly I don't care whether you think my posts are boring or not. And I will continue to point out the singular failure of the host club alignment especially when you analyse how poorly the Eagles have performed in the past two years.

Yawn

Ladder position is not an indicator of whether the host club/stand alone side model works. Fremantle are in 14th so you think it doesn't work. All Top 8 sides have aligned or standalone sides so does that mean that the model does work?

No it doesn't. However what does count is that it is patently obvious that the supposed benefits to the two WA domiciled AFL clubs having the host club alignment in place is not successful. What is also patently and demonstrably obvious the significant damage to the integrity of the WAFL competition.

Patently obvious to you as that's the only answer you're looking for.

The integrity of the WAFL competition has been harmed far more by the decisions of the WAFL clubs over the last 30+ years than it has been by the AFL clubs seeking the host club arrangements.

Anyway Ross Lyon needs to go. Overrated and underperforming but unfortunately he's still got a few years to go on his contract.

The 2016 WAFL GF was completely and utterly prostituted by the host club alignment. Perhaps you can provide at least two decisions that affected the integrity of the WAFL competition than that.

Swan42 I've already listed more than 2 decisions on other threads.

Hence why I find your repetitive and narrow minded rhetoric so boring

Its one of the reasons I won't respond to 42s queries..

And I find yours, TT et al trying to deflect from the incompetence of the WAFC and the impact of such incompetence on the integrity and viability of the WAFL bewildering in the extreme, disingenuous and removed from reality.

What I also find incomprehensible is your unwillingness to provide a critique of the West Coast Eagles's coach given you don't seem to have any reluctance to comment on Ross Lyon.

Swan42 I'm not sure if you've noticed but this thread is titled 'Ross Lyon Staying or Going?'

I know this might be hard for you to grasp but it could explain why the majority of people commenting on this thread are discussing whether they think Ross should stay or go.

Tiger Tales wrote:

swan42 wrote:

Unholytugboat wrote:

Tiger Tales wrote:

swan42 wrote:

Tiger Tales wrote:

swan42 wrote:

Tiger Tales wrote:

swan42 wrote:

Tiger Tales wrote: Geez Swan42 hardly a surprise that you want to refer every single conversation back to host club alignment. To be honest your comments have become boring.

It's time for Ross to go because the Dockers have failed to adapt their game plan which allows them to kick enough goals to win games. Are the Dockers in a better position now than when Ross arrived? No they are not.

Frankly I don't care whether you think my posts are boring or not. And I will continue to point out the singular failure of the host club alignment especially when you analyse how poorly the Eagles have performed in the past two years.

Yawn

Ladder position is not an indicator of whether the host club/stand alone side model works. Fremantle are in 14th so you think it doesn't work. All Top 8 sides have aligned or standalone sides so does that mean that the model does work?

No it doesn't. However what does count is that it is patently obvious that the supposed benefits to the two WA domiciled AFL clubs having the host club alignment in place is not successful. What is also patently and demonstrably obvious the significant damage to the integrity of the WAFL competition.

Patently obvious to you as that's the only answer you're looking for.

The integrity of the WAFL competition has been harmed far more by the decisions of the WAFL clubs over the last 30+ years than it has been by the AFL clubs seeking the host club arrangements.

Anyway Ross Lyon needs to go. Overrated and underperforming but unfortunately he's still got a few years to go on his contract.

The 2016 WAFL GF was completely and utterly prostituted by the host club alignment. Perhaps you can provide at least two decisions that affected the integrity of the WAFL competition than that.

Swan42 I've already listed more than 2 decisions on other threads.

Hence why I find your repetitive and narrow minded rhetoric so boring

Its one of the reasons I won't respond to 42s queries..

And I find yours, TT et al trying to deflect from the incompetence of the WAFC and the impact of such incompetence on the integrity and viability of the WAFL bewildering in the extreme, disingenuous and removed from reality.

What I also find incomprehensible is your unwillingness to provide a critique of the West Coast Eagles's coach given you don't seem to have any reluctance to comment on Ross Lyon.

Swan42 I'm not sure if you've noticed but this thread is titled 'Ross Lyon Staying or Going?'

I know this might be hard for you to grasp but it could explain why the majority of people commenting on this thread are discussing whether they think Ross should stay or go.

Interesting non-response to one of my posts TT. Perhaps it required a bit of "fair and balanced" reporting as neither Freo nor Ross Lyon will be parting company in the near future. Categorically he is staying at Freo.

Dwert wrote:

Unholytugboat wrote: After today's effort Lyon might be the first rat to jump ship...and he has form as a rat.

Beat me to it Tugboat. Two consecutive 100pt losses will mean the pressure builds.

You would have to think so.

Listening to callers on 6pr after the game they brought up an issue that is glaringly obvious, why are the media so shit scared of Lyon and why aren't they putting the serious acid on him? Any other coach after two disgusting performance like that would be hammered by the press, if it was in Melbourne he would be looking down the Barrel , as one caller said the local press are so shit scared of being locked out of a two team town the acid stays off.

Pretty clear responses to your posts Swan 42.

Maybe if you put your thesaurus down, you might grasp the very basic concepts of my response. To bring you up to speed:
1. I've already given the answers to your question about how the WAFL has compromised its own integrity in another thread.
2. This thread is about Ross Lyon not Adam Simpson (or any other coach) hence why Ross Lyons future is the topic of this discussion.
3. Your responses are predictable and as such, extremely boring.

58shark wrote:

swan42 wrote:

58shark wrote:

swan42 wrote:

58shark wrote: Rosco has to stay because if he does another runner, his public currency will be worth less than the Bolivian boliviano.

58s I would think you should be more concerned with what is happening in terms of the Eagles' coaches.

So you don't want me to post any comments on your beloved dockers?

I am a member of the Swan Districts Football Club. I have never been a member of Freo. I have watched one game Freo have played this year out of 21. I watched the first three or so minutes of the game today. They are not my "beloved Dockers". You can comment on whichever topics tickle your fancy.

However, I would think you would be more concerned about the failure of your team to make its presence felt in the top 8.

To coin one of your phrases...."utter crap". Reading your past posts, you are a "closet" dockers supporter.

he is a docker through and through always has been, he has 50 cents each way - bags the alignment orchestrated by the dockers and then leaps to their defence at every single post on here , even after completely embarrassing performances like we have seen the last two weeks. as you stated he is full of utter crap.

Bazza wrote:

Dwert wrote:

Unholytugboat wrote: After today's effort Lyon might be the first rat to jump ship...and he has form as a rat.

Beat me to it Tugboat. Two consecutive 100pt losses will mean the pressure builds.

You would have to think so.

Listening to callers on 6pr after the game they brought up an issue that is glaringly obvious, why are the media so shit scared of Lyon and why aren't they putting the serious acid on him? Any other coach after two disgusting performance like that would be hammered by the press, if it was in Melbourne he would be looking down the Barrel , as one caller said the local press are so shit scared of being locked out of a two team town the acid stays off.

Would have thought the journos would be lining up to have a crack and if they get locked out who'd care. The coaches responses in the post match press conferences as as boring and predictable as Swan42s drivel.

Three 100 point losses in a year with a few other big loses and sitting 14th on the ladder should have any coach in the crosshairs.

I think that if the media did drop the acid on them and got locked out, the clubs would be the ones that would need to fold first. I don't think the sponsors and certainly not the members and supporters would be impressed with a lockout.
Anyway, back on topic, I don't give a damn whether Ross stays or goes, but he certainly needs to front up and answer some questions - and answer them honestly for the sake of their membership.

Tiger Tales wrote:

Bazza wrote:

Dwert wrote:

Unholytugboat wrote: After today's effort Lyon might be the first rat to jump ship...and he has form as a rat.

Beat me to it Tugboat. Two consecutive 100pt losses will mean the pressure builds.

You would have to think so.

Listening to callers on 6pr after the game they brought up an issue that is glaringly obvious, why are the media so shit scared of Lyon and why aren't they putting the serious acid on him? Any other coach after two disgusting performance like that would be hammered by the press, if it was in Melbourne he would be looking down the Barrel , as one caller said the local press are so shit scared of being locked out of a two team town the acid stays off.

Would have thought the journos would be lining up to have a crack and if they get locked out who'd care. The coaches responses in the post match press conferences as as boring and predictable as Swan42s drivel.

Three 100 point losses in a year with a few other big loses and sitting 14th on the ladder should have any coach in the crosshairs.

Lyons miserable monotone presentation style should of worn thin by now.

Yep and with now the lowest percentage in the league, one has to wonder if anything has changed with the mindset of Lyon, I don't think it ever will, the lack of scoring is deplorable and his defensive tactics are ancient history.

Tiger Tales wrote: Pretty clear responses to your posts Swan 42.

Maybe if you put your thesaurus down, you might grasp the very basic concepts of my response. To bring you up to speed:
1. I've already given the answers to your question about how the WAFL has compromised its own integrity in another thread.
2. This thread is about Ross Lyon not Adam Simpson (or any other coach) hence why Ross Lyons future is the topic of this discussion.
3. Your responses are predictable and as such, extremely boring.

Apparently another non-reply to a post of mine.

Bazza wrote:

Tiger Tales wrote:

Bazza wrote:

Dwert wrote:

Unholytugboat wrote: After today's effort Lyon might be the first rat to jump ship...and he has form as a rat.

Beat me to it Tugboat. Two consecutive 100pt losses will mean the pressure builds.

You would have to think so.

Listening to callers on 6pr after the game they brought up an issue that is glaringly obvious, why are the media so shit scared of Lyon and why aren't they putting the serious acid on him? Any other coach after two disgusting performance like that would be hammered by the press, if it was in Melbourne he would be looking down the Barrel , as one caller said the local press are so shit scared of being locked out of a two team town the acid stays off.

Would have thought the journos would be lining up to have a crack and if they get locked out who'd care. The coaches responses in the post match press conferences as as boring and predictable as Swan42s drivel.

Three 100 point losses in a year with a few other big loses and sitting 14th on the ladder should have any coach in the crosshairs.

Lyons miserable monotone presentation style should of worn thin by now.

Yep and with now the lowest percentage in the league, one has to wonder if anything has changed with the mindset of Lyon, I don't think it ever will, the lack of scoring is deplorable and his defensive tactics are ancient history.

Since you are not a Freo supporter shouldn't you actually want Lyon to stay coaching Freo?