Anchor it is vitally important for a club like Richmond to retain all of it's star players. Look at Adelaide, losing Kurt Tippet has hurt them big time. Richmond more so have been starved of success for far too long. It would be devastating for them to lose any of those yet to re-sign and I would have no respect for them if they went else where for any reason. They should stick with the Tigers who seem to building towards something.
You forgot to mention Zac Clarke, who re-signed the other day until 2015. I had just about written him off but he has been impressive since coming back into the side. He is now holding his marks and lifted his work rate. With still big ?? over Sandi and Griffen going down for 12 months I reckon the club acted swiftly to secure Zac Clarke.