TOPIC:

I’m pissed at Subiaco buying flag after flag and pretending its not the free money they get that makes them successful. However, they are a G7 club and if the pi$$weak WAFC had some balls, they would attempt to equalise the league. But how can they do that when they foster 2 bogus AFL clubs? As far as I am concerned, I would rather support a G7 club in front of an AFL club even if it is Subi.

Senior Seagull wrote:

BC wrote: Yes I know...but correcting the misguided is in my DNA.

Sorry BC I have to correct you as you neglected to add the following 3 words after misguided .....
bitter, twisted and envious.

Gotta love leedy and PN supporters of clubs that have a poor record regarding salary cap breaches

Haha, flogging a dead horse there SS, that old chest nut comes out when you have nothing left in the tank The difference with us and you routers is that we made the call the WAFC about the ($5K) oversight, I don't see anyone at $ubi calling the WAFC for the $250k breach year in, year out. The offer that Zac Clarke took from you blokes must have been a ripper because WP offered him a over $30k with coaching attached to that.

58shark wrote: I’m pissed at Subiaco buying flag after flag and pretending its not the free money they get that makes them successful. However, they are a G7 club and if the pi$$weak WAFC had some balls, they would attempt to equalise the league. But how can they do that when they foster 2 bogus AFL clubs? As far as I am concerned, I would rather support a G7 club in front of an AFL club even if it is Subi.

To be honest 58 if I were a supporter of another G7 club I'd be pissed too. But as it stands at the moment Subi has not been found to be doing anything outside the rules and has been very successful. If at some point in the future they're exposed for breaking the salary cap or reporting irregularities like other clubs then I'll be the first to apologise to all on here and say I disown the club and its success....but until that happens or should I say if it happens, I apologise for nothing and certainly don't begrudge my club's success.

Has there been a Subi coach that has gone on from their success at Subi and made it at AFL level in recent years? Can't think of any Scott Waters was found out at the Saints, what about German who couldn't win a game at Peel, if only the WAFC was as vigilant in the Waafl in the Anateurs were against c grade sides.

Clarke’s manager rang Swans for an offer, needless to say they never got a call back once he was shipped around so Subi were always winning that battle.
Boekhurst manager wanted money up front before signing so off to East Freo he went for cash up front.

Peter North wrote: Has there been a Subi coach that has gone on from their success at Subi and made it at AFL level in recent years? Can't think of any Scott Waters was found out at the Saints, what about German who couldn't win a game at Peel, if only the WAFC was as vigilant in the Waafl in the Anateurs were against c grade sides.

what you clowns need to remember is that in Schofield's first year in 2013 we finished second last ahead of the chunder. Since then we've appeared in every GF winning 2 out of 4 and only beaten by what is essentially an AFL reserves side which had a number of players who would have been in Freo's best 22 at the back end of the season if they made the AFL finals. It all started with Germo who was a senior assistant at both Hawthorn and WCE and was instrumental putting the professionalism which still exists today, successfully carried on by Watters, stalled under Waterman and flourished with Schofield. Say what you like about Schoey but he has runs on the board and I don't see too many other WAFL coaches being chased by AFL teams at the minute who would have done their due diligence on whether he's got the goods or is falsely coveted by being in a privileged position.

BC wrote:

58shark wrote: I’m pissed at Subiaco buying flag after flag and pretending its not the free money they get that makes them successful. However, they are a G7 club and if the pi$$weak WAFC had some balls, they would attempt to equalise the league. But how can they do that when they foster 2 bogus AFL clubs? As far as I am concerned, I would rather support a G7 club in front of an AFL club even if it is Subi.

To be honest 58 if I were a supporter of another G7 club I'd be pissed too. But as it stands at the moment Subi has not been found to be doing anything outside the rules and has been very successful. If at some point in the future they're exposed for breaking the salary cap or reporting irregularities like other clubs then I'll be the first to apologise to all on here and say I disown the club and its success....but until that happens or should I say if it happens, I apologise for nothing and certainly don't begrudge my club's success.

It will always piss me, but what tempers the situation is that I doubt that any other G7 club would not have done the same if they were in Subi’s situation. Unpalatable but true.

Updates: Murray Newman now listed again at Swans, clearance from Kelmscott pending. West Perth's Allan Garlett has joined Noranda, who are also the pending destination for Dennis Colbung (West Perth) and Brennan Stack (Perth).

UPDATED 22/12/17

CLAREMONT

In: Tom Curren (Sandringham), Kane Mitchell (Returns), Isaac Wallace (Murray Bushrangers)

Out: Wil Powell (Gold Coast), Zac Langdon (GWS), Jake Patmore (Port Adelaide), Matt Guelfi (Essendon), Bailey Banfield (Fremantle), Callan England (West Coast)

EAST FREMANTLE

In: Jordan Snadden (Returns), Cameron Loersch (AFL), Jonathon Griffen (Returns), Jarrad Jansen (Returns), Nick Kommer (AFL), James Bristow (Returns), Jacob Green (Returns), Fraser Perry (Returns), Blaine Boekhorst (AFL), Sean Fletcher (Swan Districts), Jack Belchelli (Wesley Curtin), Jesse Wynne (Claremont), Russell Wynne (Claremont)

Out: Matthew Watson (Victoria), Jake Fletcher (Subiaco), Jesse Crichton (Harvey-Brunswick-Leschenault), Andrew Stephen (Retired), Oliver Parish (Travelling), Andrew Stokes (Geraldton), Cameron Symonds (MIA)

EAST PERTH

In: Sharrod Wellingham (AFL), Oscar Allen (West Coast), Liam Ryan (West Coast), Brayden Ainsworth (West Coast), Ryan Burrows (West Coast), Callan England (West Coast), Jarrod Brander (West Coast), Jack Petruccelle (West Coast), Hamish Brayshaw (West Coast), Tony Olango (West Coast), Jackson Ramsay (Returns), Tom Gorter (Returns)

Out: Brandon Starcevich (Brisbane), Scott Jones (Fremantle), Mitchell Lague (Perth), Fraser Barns (Perth)

PEEL THUNDER

In: Scott Jones (Fremantle), Bailey Banfield (Fremantle), Andrew Brayshaw (Fremantle), Adam Cerra (Fremantle), Hugh Dixon (Fremantle), Mitch Crowden (Fremantle), Tom North (Fremantle), Lloyd Meek (Fremantle), Sam Switkowski (Fremantle), Stefan Giro (Fremantle), Ben Howlett (Returns), Kalani Scarrott (Subiaco)

Out: Aaron Naughton (Western Bulldogs), Rory O’Brien (Retired)

PERTH

In: Matt Taylor (Returns), Mitchell Lague (East Perth), Corey Yeo (Williamstown), Callum Collard (Returns), Richard Bourne (East Fremantle), Fraser Barns (East Perth)

Out: Gordon Narrier (North Melbourne), Aidan Tropiano (South Australia), Liam McKenna (Travelling), Brent Latch (Travelling), Michael Sinclair (Study), Brennan Stack (Noranda)

SOUTH FREMANTLE

In: Nick Suban (AFL), Zachary Dent (East Perth)

Out: Matthew Gundry (Sandringham), Jarrod Garlett (Carlton), Josh Pullman (Retired), Tim Kelly (Geelong), Ryan Burrows (West Coast), Mitchell Dzelebdzic (West Perth)

SUBIACO

In: Ben Newton (AFL), Josh Deluca (Returns), Drew Rohde (West Perth), Rhys Waters (Returns), Sean Bradley (Returns),Tom Smith (Returns), Luke Norriss (Returns), Andrew Vawser (Returns), Hayden Yarran (Returns), Jakob Atkinson (Perth), Casey Brown (North Fremantle), Travis Cleggett (Collie/Peel Thunder), Josh Porteous (Peel Thunder), David Ehlers (Claremont), Matthew Ehlers (Claremont), Jack Fletcher (East Fremantle), Kaidyn Fullgrabe (West Perth), Lewis Krakouer (East Fremantle), Zac Clarke (AFL)

Out: Liam Ryan (West Coast), Brayden Ainsworth (West Coast), Kyron Hayden (North Melbourne), Ben Miller (Richmond), Liam Baker (Richmond), Fraser Foley (West Perth), James Garcia (Travelling), Matthew Bogensperger (Work), David Madut (Victoria), Wayde Twomey (Retired), Adam Creeper

SWAN DISTRICTS

In: Murray Newman (Returns)

Out: Sam Taylor (GWS), Jamie Bennell (Victoria), Tallen Ames (Retired), Ryan Crowley (Retired), Clancee Pearce (Retired)

WEST PERTH

In: Fraser Foley (Subiaco), Mitchell Dzelebdzic (South Fremantle), Matthew Johnson (Returns)

Out: Oscar Allen (West Coast), Nick Rodda (Williamstown), Scott Simpson (Retired), Dennis Colbung (Noranda), Allan Garlett (Noranda)

Lions Den wrote: Updates: Murray Newman now listed again at Swans, clearance from Kelmscott pending. West Perth's Allan Garlett has joined Noranda, who are also the pending destination for Dennis Colbung (West Perth) and Brennan Stack (Perth).

UPDATED 22/12/17

CLAREMONT

In: Tom Curren (Sandringham), Kane Mitchell (Returns), Isaac Wallace (Murray Bushrangers)

Out: Wil Powell (Gold Coast), Zac Langdon (GWS), Jake Patmore (Port Adelaide), Matt Guelfi (Essendon), Bailey Banfield (Fremantle), Callan England (West Coast)

EAST FREMANTLE

In: Jordan Snadden (Returns), Cameron Loersch (AFL), Jonathon Griffen (Returns), Jarrad Jansen (Returns), Nick Kommer (AFL), James Bristow (Returns), Jacob Green (Returns), Fraser Perry (Returns), Blaine Boekhorst (AFL), Sean Fletcher (Swan Districts), Jack Belchelli (Wesley Curtin), Jesse Wynne (Claremont), Russell Wynne (Claremont)

Out: Matthew Watson (Victoria), Jake Fletcher (Subiaco), Jesse Crichton (Harvey-Brunswick-Leschenault), Andrew Stephen (Retired), Oliver Parish (Travelling), Andrew Stokes (Geraldton), Cameron Symonds (MIA)

EAST PERTH

In: Sharrod Wellingham (AFL), Oscar Allen (West Coast), Liam Ryan (West Coast), Brayden Ainsworth (West Coast), Ryan Burrows (West Coast), Callan England (West Coast), Jarrod Brander (West Coast), Jack Petruccelle (West Coast), Hamish Brayshaw (West Coast), Tony Olango (West Coast), Jackson Ramsay (Returns), Tom Gorter (Returns)

Out: Brandon Starcevich (Brisbane), Scott Jones (Fremantle), Mitchell Lague (Perth), Fraser Barns (Perth)

PEEL THUNDER

In: Scott Jones (Fremantle), Bailey Banfield (Fremantle), Andrew Brayshaw (Fremantle), Adam Cerra (Fremantle), Hugh Dixon (Fremantle), Mitch Crowden (Fremantle), Tom North (Fremantle), Lloyd Meek (Fremantle), Sam Switkowski (Fremantle), Stefan Giro (Fremantle), Ben Howlett (Returns), Kalani Scarrott (Subiaco)

Out: Aaron Naughton (Western Bulldogs), Rory O’Brien (Retired)

PERTH

In: Matt Taylor (Returns), Mitchell Lague (East Perth), Corey Yeo (Williamstown), Callum Collard (Returns), Richard Bourne (East Fremantle), Fraser Barns (East Perth)

Out: Gordon Narrier (North Melbourne), Aidan Tropiano (South Australia), Liam McKenna (Travelling), Brent Latch (Travelling), Michael Sinclair (Study), Brennan Stack (Noranda)

SOUTH FREMANTLE

In: Nick Suban (AFL), Zachary Dent (East Perth)

Out: Matthew Gundry (Sandringham), Jarrod Garlett (Carlton), Josh Pullman (Retired), Tim Kelly (Geelong), Ryan Burrows (West Coast), Mitchell Dzelebdzic (West Perth)

SUBIACO

In: Ben Newton (AFL), Josh Deluca (Returns), Drew Rohde (West Perth), Rhys Waters (Returns), Sean Bradley (Returns),Tom Smith (Returns), Luke Norriss (Returns), Andrew Vawser (Returns), Hayden Yarran (Returns), Jakob Atkinson (Perth), Casey Brown (North Fremantle), Travis Cleggett (Collie/Peel Thunder), Josh Porteous (Peel Thunder), David Ehlers (Claremont), Matthew Ehlers (Claremont), Jack Fletcher (East Fremantle), Kaidyn Fullgrabe (West Perth), Lewis Krakouer (East Fremantle), Zac Clarke (AFL)

Out: Liam Ryan (West Coast), Brayden Ainsworth (West Coast), Kyron Hayden (North Melbourne), Ben Miller (Richmond), Liam Baker (Richmond), Fraser Foley (West Perth), James Garcia (Year off), Matthew Bogensperger (Work), David Madut (Victoria), Wayde Twomey (Retired), Adam Creeper

SWAN DISTRICTS

In: Murray Newman (Returns)

Out: Sam Taylor (GWS), Jamie Bennell (Victoria), Tallen Ames (Retired), Ryan Crowley (Retired), Clancee Pearce (Retired)

WEST PERTH

In: Fraser Foley (Subiaco), Mitchell Dzelebdzic (South Fremantle), Matthew Johnson (Returns)

Out: Oscar Allen (West Coast), Nick Rodda (Williamstown), Scott Simpson (Retired), Dennis Colbung (Noranda), Allan Garlett (Noranda)

Not so sure about that in for SD...a possible maybe

Why has big Madut gone East?