TOPIC:

Obviously some teams are far more undisciplined than others - even when the personnel changes from year to year Truly bizarre figures

Colts Frees 2012
West Perth +57
East Fremantle +38
Claremont +36
South Fremantle +32
Peel +7
Swan Districts +0
East Perth -5
Subiaco -19
Perth -65

Colts Frees 2013
East Perth +60
Claremont +9
South Fremantle +9
West Perth +5
East Fremantle +3
Perth -16
Subiaco -20
Swan Districts -34

La Hincha wrote: Obviously some teams are far more undisciplined than others - even when the personnel changes from year to year Truly bizarre figures

Colts Frees 2012
West Perth +57
East Fremantle +38
Claremont +36
South Fremantle +32
Peel +7
Swan Districts +0
East Perth -5
Subiaco -19
Perth -65

Colts Frees 2013
East Perth +60
Claremont +9
South Fremantle +9
West Perth +5
East Fremantle +3
Perth -16
Subiaco -20
Swan Districts -34

LaH I am not sure what you are intimating. You don't seriously think that all the teams should have a nett balance of zero.

swan42 wrote:

La Hincha wrote: Obviously some teams are far more undisciplined than others - even when the personnel changes from year to year Truly bizarre figures

Colts Frees 2012
West Perth +57
East Fremantle +38
Claremont +36
South Fremantle +32
Peel +7
Swan Districts +0
East Perth -5
Subiaco -19
Perth -65

Colts Frees 2013
East Perth +60
Claremont +9
South Fremantle +9
West Perth +5
East Fremantle +3
Perth -16
Subiaco -20
Swan Districts -34

LaH I am not sure what you are intimating. You don't seriously think that all the teams should have a nett balance of zero.

Nope, not a net balance of zero. But I find it hard to believe that last year Perth were "that" much more undisciplined than all others and this year East Perth are so much more disciplined than the rest. Not from all the matches I've seen anyway.

La Hincha wrote:

swan42 wrote:

La Hincha wrote: Obviously some teams are far more undisciplined than others - even when the personnel changes from year to year Truly bizarre figures

Colts Frees 2012
West Perth +57
East Fremantle +38
Claremont +36
South Fremantle +32
Peel +7
Swan Districts +0
East Perth -5
Subiaco -19
Perth -65

Colts Frees 2013
East Perth +60
Claremont +9
South Fremantle +9
West Perth +5
East Fremantle +3
Perth -16
Subiaco -20
Swan Districts -34

LaH I am not sure what you are intimating. You don't seriously think that all the teams should have a nett balance of zero.

Nope, not a net balance of zero. But I find it hard to believe that last year Perth were "that" much more undisciplined than all others and this year East Perth are so much more disciplined than the rest. Not from all the matches I've seen anyway.

oh that I could comment abt this but the EP boys are a little more aware this year but certainly from the games I have watched (all of them) the disparaity is a big shock.

might have something to do with the assistant coaches of the East Perth colts - A.Selwood, S.Selwood and L.Shuey

MarkOlsen wrote: might have something to do with the assistant coaches of the East Perth colts - A.Selwood, S.Selwood and L.Shuey

Oh that they were, are or will be assistant coaches, not yet anyway! Maybe next year or when the Weagles start training at lathlain park

La Hincha wrote:

swan42 wrote:

La Hincha wrote: Obviously some teams are far more undisciplined than others - even when the personnel changes from year to year Truly bizarre figures

Colts Frees 2012
West Perth +57
East Fremantle +38
Claremont +36
South Fremantle +32
Peel +7
Swan Districts +0
East Perth -5
Subiaco -19
Perth -65

Colts Frees 2013
East Perth +60
Claremont +9
South Fremantle +9
West Perth +5
East Fremantle +3
Perth -16
Subiaco -20
Swan Districts -34

LaH I am not sure what you are intimating. You don't seriously think that all the teams should have a nett balance of zero.

Nope, not a net balance of zero. But I find it hard to believe that last year Perth were "that" much more undisciplined than all others and this year East Perth are so much more disciplined than the rest. Not from all the matches I've seen anyway.

Complete load of rubbish. If an umpire sees a free he pays it. If he doesn't he calls play on. It does my head in that still so many people complain they get a tough run with umps and the count should be even. Sorry LH but this is a rubbish thread

Sacko wrote:

La Hincha wrote:

swan42 wrote:

La Hincha wrote: Obviously some teams are far more undisciplined than others - even when the personnel changes from year to year Truly bizarre figures

Colts Frees 2012
West Perth +57
East Fremantle +38
Claremont +36
South Fremantle +32
Peel +7
Swan Districts +0
East Perth -5
Subiaco -19
Perth -65

Colts Frees 2013
East Perth +60
Claremont +9
South Fremantle +9
West Perth +5
East Fremantle +3
Perth -16
Subiaco -20
Swan Districts -34

LaH I am not sure what you are intimating. You don't seriously think that all the teams should have a nett balance of zero.

Nope, not a net balance of zero. But I find it hard to believe that last year Perth were "that" much more undisciplined than all others and this year East Perth are so much more disciplined than the rest. Not from all the matches I've seen anyway.

Complete load of rubbish. If an umpire sees a free he pays it. If he doesn't he calls play on. It does my head in that still so many people complain they get a tough run with umps and the count should be even. Sorry LH but this is a rubbish thread

Well said sacko, this rubbish about favouring teams is crap and should be left to the dreamers of the footy world. An ump at this level simply cannot afford the luxury of favourtism if he wants to keep his job.

La Hincha wrote: Obviously some teams are far more undisciplined than others - even when the personnel changes from year to year Truly bizarre figures

Colts Frees 2012
West Perth +57
East Fremantle +38
Claremont +36
South Fremantle +32
Peel +7
Swan Districts +0
East Perth -5
Subiaco -19
Perth -65

Colts Frees 2013
East Perth +60
Claremont +9
South Fremantle +9
West Perth +5
East Fremantle +3
Perth -16
Subiaco -20
Swan Districts -34

I find these free kick stats very interesting LH & I did up a similar table on footygoss last year for the League! Any chance of compiling one for the League this year?

Beasley Hutton wrote:

La Hincha wrote: Obviously some teams are far more undisciplined than others - even when the personnel changes from year to year Truly bizarre figures

Colts Frees 2012
West Perth +57
East Fremantle +38
Claremont +36
South Fremantle +32
Peel +7
Swan Districts +0
East Perth -5
Subiaco -19
Perth -65

Colts Frees 2013
East Perth +60
Claremont +9
South Fremantle +9
West Perth +5
East Fremantle +3
Perth -16
Subiaco -20
Swan Districts -34

I find these free kick stats very interesting LH & I did up a similar table on footygoss last year for the League! Any chance of compiling one for the League this year?

Yeah, I'll try to get around to it mate. Takes hours adding the pluses and minus for a year.

The one thing I do know is when I watch league, I rarely complain or feel bitter about umpiring. It's not great but it's ok.

At colts level even when I watch a game as a neutral I could tear my hair out.

In the colts game between S and SD last week at half time the tally was 9 to 2 in favour of SD even though S were dominating the game. I don't know what was said at half time but by the end of the game it was 12 all.