TOPIC:

Grassy wrote: How do you back up your claim about Peelmantle being the lesser of 2 Evils?

Read it again, I said Subiaco are the lesser of 2 evils

Dusty wrote:

Grassy wrote: Oh no Mike,Dusty came out of nowhere with that claim.Perfectly apt for this thread.

Grassy how do you start a new topic? I want to kick the Monts section back into life with some 2s and colts chat

You need to click on the club section first where you see the list of topics then you will see a start new topic button.

Dusty wrote:

Guido 75 wrote: any new recruits on the cards for Swans /who should we get.
Bennell delisted hopely signs back with swans.

Bennell has been in advanced talks with Claremont so very little chance of him coming to Swans.

A straight swap trade for Tom Lee should suffice then!

Beasley Hutton wrote:

Dusty wrote:

Guido 75 wrote: any new recruits on the cards for Swans /who should we get.
Bennell delisted hopely signs back with swans.

Bennell has been in advanced talks with Claremont so very little chance of him coming to Swans.

A straight swap trade for Tom Lee should suffice then!

No chance

Grassy wrote: How do you back up your claim about Peelmantle being the lesser of 2 Evils?

Stinking up another thread eh well done.

Larry Bird wrote: That depends if your serious about climbing the ladder. There would be 20 players at EP that you should target before Payne. No point paying transfer fees for guys that will not help you. Haven't you learnt your lesson over the last two years.

I rate Payne but if you reckon there's better options LB can you name a couple?

Depends what position you want filled but Roche would be my first pick to make an impact on ball.

Payne won the EP best and fairest in 2014, made the state squad last year.
If you have 20 better player than him maybe you should play them in your league team and you would be playing this weekend in the league.

I have watched virtually every game he has played so take my opinion if you will. By his own admission his football has fallen off remarkably partly due to injury. A change of scenery may do him good. He struggles in the physical stakes lacks pace and his disposal is shocking. His asset is he accumulates due to his endurance. I think if I included the colts I could find twenty quite comfortably. If you want two slow ex EP wingman that can't kick next year instead of playing your own kids be my guest. But don't bang on about how great your juniors are in future.

Send the 20 to your coach, doesn't interest me.
He picked him 10 times this year so sounds like the Eagles should be paying you not Jaymie Graham.
As for Clutterbuck, wasn't helped but not being allowed to play the pre season games due to east Perth being petty, Harding shouldn't have played him till he was match fit.
Hace no interest in debating local talent with an Eagles reserves supporter, you don't have a league team to support so not really sure why you are bothered who stays and goes from from the club that wears blue and black.