TOPIC:

BC i have no problem with you going on about the alignment. You are free to do that but not on a Peel thread who's topic is titled "congratulations Peel". Please use other boards for alignment comments.

You claim in a recent post that I deleted your comments that were on topic. Yet you also stated you wouldn't be congratulating Peel. Given the topic title hopefully you can understand why your posts were removed. They were not relevant to the topic.

DW as I have stated previously.
Peel played 18 AFL players listed by Fremantle FC.
I ex AFL player recruited from PFC.
I ex AFL player recruited from SFFC.
2 Peel players.
Hardly home grown talent.

Rookie draft wrote: BC i have no problem with you going on about the alignment. You are free to do that but not on a Peel thread who's topic is titled "congratulations Peel". Please use other boards for alignment comments.

You claim in a recent post that I deleted your comments that were on topic. Yet you also stated you wouldn't be congratulating Peel. Given the topic title hopefully you can understand why your posts were removed. They were not relevant to the topic.

that's your call RD but I think you're delusional if Peel's alignment with Freo and winning the flag with 17 aligned players yesterday is not all on the same topic. if its only pats on the back you're after without any rational debate on how your team got there then that says everything to me.

If you are looking for rational debate in fairness you wouldn't go looking for a Subi supporter for their thoughts.
That they got so close yesterday compared to how WP and South went says more about WAFL inequality than Peels victory

MO: both are no good for the competition: I think that the Commission should address both issues during the review of the alignment so,

restrict the alignment clubs on the 10-8 idea -- number of players and game qualification
prevent Subiaco from doing any recruitment.

we can always review the policies if they do not work as expectted.

Demons Forever wrote: DW as I have stated previously.
Peel played 18 AFL players listed by Fremantle FC.
I ex AFL player recruited from PFC.
I ex AFL player recruited from SFFC.
2 Peel players.
Hardly home grown talent.

Fark even more so a great achievement than by Peel to gel all those non locals together than DF .....love the subtlety of your post mate....very canny indeed!

Prevent Subi from recruiting ?
Why would the Wafc now admit Subi have an advantage, I think the horse has bolted on that one!

MO -- for the same reason that they will, in all likelihood, make changes to the alignment, pressure from the other clubs. If the alignment is reformmed and Subiaco win flag after flag, they will have to change it.

Congratulations Peelmantle

Arkroyal - just saw the breaking news on channel 10 - apparently Subi have played in 10 of the last 14 grand finals, let us all know when that is not considered to be an issue to the other 6 WAFL clubs

And apparently their supporters reckon their zones are not good enough !