TOPIC:

Wright can you elaborate on that post mate....because you have totally lost me.....surely Dixon, Schoenfeld, English and Marsh have all added to the team when available?..as for points limiting....only one of them is worth 1 point, the rest 10 points each.....so you have lost me again.

​​​​​​

Point taken on the four mentioned so instead of my quote "a couple or three at the most" i'll give you are correct and I'll agree three. As for those that are unnamed by me look for the ones that were recruited to the AFL as 18 year old's and delisted without striking a blow.

So are we talking about recruiting from the Wiley days now mate in ex AFL boys in Jansen, Simpson and Snadden? Think  Eardley has proved his worth, whilst Strnadica is definitely proving his worth now Griff has retired.....whilst O'Reilly needs more time on the park to prove his worth....

Yep  agree definitely some hits and misses there amongst that lot, but surely if Tom Joyce gets delisted from Brisbane this year, EF will do their best to get the young fella back, IF he returns to WA....be disappointed if EF didn't try and recruit him.....damned if you do and damned if you don't some times.....wasted 10 points on Loersch, don't think Kommer or Boekhorst have delivered on their 10 point tags, but no such thing as a crystal ball I guess....e.g. Palmer and Masten....the former lasted a year before an unlucky non football related accident, whilst Masto has had a fair injuries in his time at MRP.......

Surely Wright isn't suggesting we don't take back ex-EF players? I think recruiting has been fine in the Monaghan era- this years looks an excellent haul in Marsh, Schoenfeld, English and Dixon- they have just been injured and missed games. Strnadica is proving his worth. Question marks on Tucker and O'Reilly still- who are only young but still playing League. Schoenfeld looked liked the best recruit in the WAFL before he hurt his knee. Don't know much about Chalmers- who was very good against Peel before also getting injured.

Boekhorst, Snadden, Loersch, Kommer and Jansen are all Wiley era- Jansen has been excellent and the others have been serviceable but inconsistent.