TOPIC:

Depending on the interpretation you cant go past Natanui, up there with Martin and Dangerfield as the best in the country when fit. Then there's Fyfe, Leon Davis, Adam Selwood

Freezin wrote:

Beasley Hutton wrote: It is just BC showing his football knowledge or more to the point lack there of yet again TOO.
Kicked 35 goals in 2011 for Collingwood including 3 in the AFL Grand Final vs Geelong and also took the mark of the year that season...hardly failing to have an impact!
Also he did his knee in 2012 and had to undergo a knee reco.

Sounds like with those stats mean Kraks was probably the player to play in the AFL over the last decade too BH.....did he even get a run through Collingwoods midfield?.......pretty sure Pendles and Dane were Collingwoods king pins in the midfield...perhaps that is what BC means by lack of impact after his stellar season in SD midfield the year before. Amazing to think the best midfielder to play WAFL over the last decade in a few folks eyes reduced to playing as a small forward from the looks of things....pity Kraks did his knee.....

I would rate Menegola slightly above Kraks tbh Freeze, I doubt whether he dominated 2010 any more than Menegola did 2015 and as you said Kraks couldn't get a gig in guts for the pies where as Menagola is a vital cog in the middle for a top 4 side

Yes freez...that's exactly what I meant. The Krak was a terrific player in the WAFL but one season as a small forward at the Pies isn't exactly setting the world on fire.

1) Kraks 2) Swooper Geapen 3) Tony Notte 4) Tallen Ames 5)Ryan Davis 6)Justin Simpson

Freezin wrote:

Beasley Hutton wrote: It is just BC showing his football knowledge or more to the point lack there of yet again TOO.
Kicked 35 goals in 2011 for Collingwood including 3 in the AFL Grand Final vs Geelong and also took the mark of the year that season...hardly failing to have an impact!
Also he did his knee in 2012 and had to undergo a knee reco.

Sounds like with those stats mean Kraks was probably the player to play in the AFL over the last decade too BH.....did he even get a run through Collingwoods midfield?.......pretty sure Pendles and Dane were Collingwoods king pins in the midfield...perhaps that is what BC means by lack of impact after his stellar season in SD midfield the year before. Amazing to think the best midfielder to play WAFL over the last decade in a few folks eyes reduced to playing as a small forward from the looks of things....pity Kraks did his knee.....

Freeze how are the Kiwis handling the Wallabys win last night.How long you been in NZ.Do you still support Australia.

Mate of course I support the Aussies....fark the kiwi's...stirred up a few kiwi mates with some banter...they hate losing any rugby match...esp to Aust...good to see the Wallabies become more competitive after that deplorable first half v ABs back in game 1.....think they were 40 odd pts to nil down....came back to lose 50 something to mid 30's....from then on Australia competed well against ABs, Saffars and the Argies....coughed up 3 winning positions in the dying mins of 3 games to draw with SA twice and lose to the ABs once....hate the kiwis mate with a passion!

Swandog wrote: 1) Kraks 2) Swooper Geapen 3) Tony Notte 4) Tallen Ames 5)Ryan Davis 6)Justin Simpson

Tend to agree mate but I didnt want to look too biased towards us so I threw in Luke Blackwell as well

Quite surprised non locals in Kraks and Swooper are rated ahead of local boys in Ames and Notte....thought local was the way go down Steel Blue way?.....only 50% local on that list BH....chuck in Smirk and Burnham and then we are over your required 60% benchmark

Freezin wrote: Quite surprised non locals in Kraks and Swooper are rated ahead of local boys in Ames and Notte....thought local was the way go down Steel Blue way?.....only 50% local on that list BH....chuck in Smirk and Burnham and then we are over your required 60% benchmark

Even that is nearly double Subi's local content in the just concluded season Freeze and more than double their Round 4 effort of a dismal 23%!

Obrien
B Smith
Schollte , Saunders has been OK as well

Tbh last 10 yrs hasn't been an embarrassment of riches for the WAFL.