TOPIC:

I am going to leave this one to other people whom are better qualified to judge, I will be looking forward to reading everybody's thoughts and opinions.

Andrew Krakouer by some way then Luke Blackwell.

this will get he bogan brethren going....good topic... do we include the aligned players qualified for WAFL finals? let's make it top 3...in no particular order Sam Menegola, Ross Young, Troppo...yep the Krak...and my apologies to Horsley, Tim Kelly, Kane Mitchell and the Shloithe.

Thats a tough one AR. I have seen so many good players. I would probably lean towards Luke Blackwell from Claremont but Andrew Krakouer, Kane Mitchell, Brad Smith, Rory O'Brien, and going back a few years Ross Young from Perth would all be in the hunt. Aaron Black always played well against Swans as well and I would put him on the possibles list as well. I'm sure I have missed a heap of good players.

you don't rate Menegola Mike? Only played a handful of games but averaged 20 plus disposals and had a huge impact for Subi in mio after coming back from a pre-season injury in 2015 which turned out to be premiership year and came second in the Sandover..... is currently an important cog in Geelongs midfield with Danger, Selwood, Duncan et al...absolute super star in the WAFL for mine.

BC wrote: you don't rate Menegola Mike? Only played a handful of games but averaged 20 plus disposals and had a huge impact for Subi in mio after coming back from a pre-season injury in 2015 which turned out to be premiership year and came second in the Sandover..... is currently an important cog in Geelongs midfield with Danger, Selwood, Duncan et al...absolute super star in the WAFL for mine.

Didn't really see much of him in the WAFL, BC so I don't feel qualified to make a judgement. Reading the game reports from that year, he did appear to be a class above the WAFL during 2015 and he has slotted in beautifully at Geelong.so you have a good point there.

My top 5..1.Andrew Krakour. Just a star..2.Sam Menagola not out of place in a top 4 AFL side...3.Luke Blackwell a player of AFL quality but was happy at Wafl level.. 4.Andrew Strijk
a A lovley polished footballer.5.Craig Wulff..Just everything a coach would love in a player.

Alistair Pickett, Mark Haynes, Brad Smith, Sam Menegola, Kyal Horsley

Krackouer, Blackwell. I wouldn't really include blokes like Menegola who haven't played much wafl

Best/most influential players
1. Dual Sandover medalist and 4 time premiership player Ali Pickett 2. Krakour 3. Blackwell 4. Johnson, 5 Black 6. Horsley 7. Brad Smith, 8. Darren Rumble 9. Wulff 10. Tim Kelly